Sum maryAcro nym SeM PER A rc ticTit le Sense M ak in g, P la ce a tta chm ent a nd E xte nd ed n etw ork s a s s o urc es o f R esilie nce in th e A rc tic .Tim e R eq uest162.0 M o.Fund in g R eq uest848.0 K ? Fund in g A gency S um maryFundin g A gencyRequestFra nce A N R198.0Norw ay R C N 100.0Sw ed en F O RM AS150.0The N eth erla nd s N W O200.0Russia R FB R200.0Pers o nnelIDRole s Fam ily N am eFir s t N am eOrg aniz a tio nCountr yFundin g S ourc e15801Conso rtiu m L eadGhera rd iJe anneUVSQ L SC EFra nceFra nce A N R15802Partn er P IBla nchardAnneUiBNorw ayNorw ay R C N 15808Partn er P IHuctinJe anM ic helUVSQ O VSQ C EA RCFra nceFra nce A N R15803Partn er P IKarls d ottirAnnaNORD REG IOSw ed enSw ed en F O RM AS15830Partn er P INik ulk in aIn gaNEFURussia n F ed era tio n th eRussia R FB R15805Partn er P IVan d er S lu ij sJe ro en P .UUNeth erla nd s th eThe N eth erla nd s N W O 177120190620211029.pdfCover20190620Page 1 Pro je ct I n fo rm atio nTit le Sense M ak in g, P la ce a tta chm ent a nd E xte nd ed n etw ork s a s s o urc es o f R esilie nce in th e A rc tic .Acro nym SeM PER A rc tic Ele m ents o f R esilie nceS ele ct a t le ast tw o[H um an e le m ents o f r e silie nce, S ocia l e le m ents o f r e silie nce, C ult u ra l e le m ents o f r e silie nce] Sta rt010 32 020 D DM MY YYYEnd 280 22 023 D DM MY YYYDura tio n36 m onth s Sum mary Rootin g it s w ork in th e A rc tic , w it h a nd fo r A rc tic c o m munit ie s, th e " S ense M ak in g, P la ce a tta chm ent, a nd E xte nd ed n etw ork s, a s s o urc es o fResilie nce in th e A rc tic " S eM PER A rc tic p ro je ct c o nso rtiu m w ill b e c o lle ctin g lo cal s to rie s o f c hanges, s h o ck s, u p heavals a nd th eir a fte rm ath s.The S eM PER A rc tic te am m em bers w ill a d opt th ese n arra tiv es a s lo cal, a nd lo caliz e d , a ncho rin g d evic es fo r r e silie nce a naly sis . M em bers o f th re eArc tic c o m munit ie s h ave b een in vo lv ed in th e p re p ara tio n o f S eM PER A rc tic a nd th e c o nso rtiu m h as c o m mit te d to w ork w it h a nd fo r th eseco m munit ie s. T heir s to rie s o f in d iv id ual a nd c o lle ctiv e a b ilit y to fa re th ro ugh s h o ck s, th re at, u nusu ally fa st c hanges, w ill c o nstit u te S eM PER A rc ticcentr a l c o rp us. T w o b ro ad c ate go rie s o f n arra tiv es th at a re e xte rn al to c o m munit ie s h ave b een id entif ie d a s p rio rit y a re a o f e nq uir y e nvir o nm enta lsc ie nce a nd p ub lic p olic y a nd r e gio nal d evelo pm ent. T he c o nso rtiu m w ill a naly se h o w th ese n arra tiv es in te ra ct w it h lo cal n arra tiv e o f r e silie nce. T hiswill a llo w fo r th e a sse ssm ent o f th eir im pacts . T he in te rd is c ip lin ary fr a m ew ork o f r e silie nce in te rp re ta tio ns w ill b e u se d to e xam in e th e r e silie ncenarra tiv es in th e lig ht o f th e d im ensio n th at a re s a lie nt fo r th e m em bers o f a rc tic c o m munit ie s. T he c o nso rtiu m w ill b e in a p osit io n to ta k e s to ck o fth e le sso ns le arn ed in it s th re e p ilo t im ple m enta tio n s it e s. I t w ill h ave d evelo ped a n arra tiv e c entr e d , lo cally r o ote d , p la ceb ase d u nd ers ta nd in g o fre silie nce w it h in a rc tic c o m munit ie s. T his u nd ers ta nd in g is k ey fo r d evelo pin g to ols a nd s tr a te gie s to in cre asin g c o m munit y r e silie nce in o th erco m munit ie s. T hese r e su lt s w ill c all fo r s h arin g th e le sso ns le arn ed w it h r e gio nal p la nners a nd p olic ym ak ers . T he c o nso rtiu m w ill th us b eco ntr ib utin g to th e k no w le d ge b ase o n g lo bal e nvir o nm enta l c hange th ro ugh r e sp ectfu l, n o np re ju d ic ed , e nq uir y o f w hat it m eans to b e a r e silie ntarc tic c o m munit y in th e 2 1st c entu ry . T he r e su lt s o f th is a naly sis w ill b e tr a nsla te d in to o ptio ns fo r a ctio ns, a t th e lo cal, r e gio nal, n atio nal a ndcir c um pola r le vels .Keyw ord sNarra tiv es; Q ualit a tiv e a naly sis ; R esilie nce; G re enla nd ; S ak ha r e p ub lic ; S yste m th in k in g; C odevelo pm ent; tr a nsd is c ip lin ary ; Revie w ersSuggeste d R evie w ers Bru no B arro ca, U niv ers it é P aris E st M arn e la V allé e, b ru no .b arro ca@ up em .fr A uré lie C ham are t, U niv ers it é G re no ble A lp es,acham are t@ gm ail. c o m Y vo n C so nk a, O ffic e fé d éra l d e la s ta tis tiq ue, y cso nk a@ gm ail. c o mRevie w ers T o A vo id Jo an N ym and L ars e n, I c ela nd C onflic t o f in te re st a s s h e is P I o f th e N unata ry uk p ro je ct in w hic h m em bers o f th is c o nso rtiu m a re p artic ip atin gin to . P ete r S chw eit z e r, A ustr ia , V ie nna U niv ers it y C onflic t o f in te re st a s h e is P I o f th e N unata ry uk p ro je ct in w hic h m em bers o f th is c o nso rtiu mare p artic ip atin g in to . G ary K ofin as, U SA , U niv ers it y o f A la sk a; M atth ew B erm an, U niv ers it y o f A la sk a, S la va S had rin , R ussia n a cad em y o fScie nce S ib eria n b ra nch a ll a re c o a uth o rs c o P I fo r s e vera l m em bers o f th e c o nso rtiu m . Suggeste d I n te rn atio nal C onfe re ncesSuggeste d I n te rn atio nal C onfe re ncesIn te rn atio nal C ongre ss o f A rc tic S ocia l S cie nce E uro pean G eo physic al U nio n a sse m bly A rc tic C ir c le , R eyk ja vik , I c ela nd Arc tic N et, C anad a 177120190620211029.pdfProject Information20190620Page 2 Partic ip atin g O rg aniz a tio nsOrgIdOrg . N am eOrg . T ypeCit yCountr yOrg . R ole15796NORD REG IOAcad em ic , T ra in in gand R ese arc hSto ck ho lmSW EAward edOrg aniz a tio n15811North E aste rn F ed era l U niv ers it y in Y ak uts kAcad em ic , T ra in in gand R ese arc hYak uts kRU SAward edOrg aniz a tio n15797Univ ers it y o f B erg enAcad em ic , T ra in in gand R ese arc hBerg enNORAward edOrg aniz a tio n15799Univ ers it é V ers a ille S ain t Q uentin L ab ora to ir e d es S cie nces d u C lim at e t d el'E nvir o nnem entAcad em ic , T ra in in gand R ese arc hGif s u rYvetteFR AAward edOrg aniz a tio n15800Univ ers it é V ers a ille s S ain t Q uentin O bse rv erv ato ir e V ers a ille s S ain t Q uentin Cult u re s E nvir o nnem ent A rc tiq ue R ep re se nta tio n C lim atAcad em ic , T ra in in gand R ese arc hGuyanco urtFR AAward edOrg aniz a tio n15798Utr e cht U niv ers it y Copern ic us I n stit u te fo r S usta in ab le D evelo pm entAcad em ic , T ra in in gand R ese arc hUtr e chtNLDAward edOrg aniz a tio n Org . 1 5796 N ORD REG IONam eNORD REG IOAcro nym NORD REG IO Org . T yp eAcad em ic , T ra in in g a nd R ese arc h Org aniz a tio n R ole Award ed O rg aniz a tio n Addre ss L in e 1 Holm am ir a le ns V äg 1 0, S kep psh o lm enAddre ss L in e 2 PO B oxBox 1 658Cit y T ow nSto ck ho lmSta te P ro vin ceSto ck ho lmCountr y SW EPosta l Z IP c o deSE1 11 8 6 S Web sit e www.N ord re gio .o rgTw it te r H and le Nord re gio Org . 1 5811 N orth E aste rn F ed era l U niv ers it y in Y ak uts kNam eNorth E aste rn F ed era l U niv ers it y in Y ak uts kAcro nym NEFU Org . T yp eAcad em ic , T ra in in g a nd R ese arc h Org aniz a tio n R ole Award ed O rg aniz a tio n Addre ss L in e 1 58 B elin sk y s trAddre ss L in e 2 PO B oxCit y T ow nYak uts kSta te P ro vin ceRep ub lic o f S ak ha Y ak utia Countr y RU SPosta l Z IP c o de677000 Web sit e http s w ww.s v fu .r uTw it te r H and le Org . 1 5797 U niv ers it y o f B erg enNam eUniv ers it y o f B erg enAcro nym UiB Org . T yp eAcad em ic , T ra in in g a nd R ese arc h 177120190620211029.pdfOrganizations20190620Page 3 Org aniz a tio n R ole Award ed O rg aniz a tio n Addre ss L in e 1 Park veie n 9Addre ss L in e 2 PO B ox7805Cit y T ow nBerg enSta te P ro vin ceHord ala ndCountr y NORPosta l Z IP c o de5020 Web sit e http s w ww.u ib .n o e ns v tTw it te r H and le Org . 1 5799 U niv ers it é V ers a ille S ain t Q uentin L ab ora to ir e d es S cie nces d u C lim at e t d e l'E nvir o nnem entNam eUniv ers it é V ers a ille S ain t Q uentin L ab ora to ir e d es S cie nces d u C lim at e t d e l'E nvir o nnem entAcro nym UVSQ L SC E Org . T yp eAcad em ic , T ra in in g a nd R ese arc h Org aniz a tio n R ole Award ed O rg aniz a tio n Addre ss L in e 1 CEA S acla y, O rm e le s M eris ie rsAddre ss L in e 2 PO B oxCit y T ow nGif s u r Y vetteSta te P ro vin ceCountr y FR APosta l Z IP c o de91190 Web sit e http s w ww.ls c e.ip sl. frTw it te r H and le Org . 1 5800 U niv ers it é V ers a ille s S ain t Q uentin O bse rv erv ato ir e V ers a ille s S ain t Q uentin C ult u re s E nvir o nnem ent A rc tiq ue R ep re se nta tio nClim atNam eUniv ers it é V ers a ille s S ain t Q uentin O bse rv erv ato ir e V ers a ille s S ain t Q uentin C ult u re s E nvir o nnem ent A rc tiq ue R ep re se nta tio nClim atAcro nym UVSQ O VSQ C EA RC Org . T yp eAcad em ic , T ra in in g a nd R ese arc h Org aniz a tio nRole Award ed O rg aniz a tio n Addre ss L in e 1 11 B oule vard d 'A le m bertAddre ss L in e 2 PO B oxCit y T ow nGuyanco urtSta te P ro vin ceCountr y FR APosta l Z IP c o de78280 Web sit e www.c earc .frTw it te r H and le Org . 1 5798 U tr e cht U niv ers it y Copern ic us I n stit u te fo r S usta in ab le D evelo pm entNam eUtr e cht U niv ers it y Copern ic us I n stit u te fo r S usta in ab le D evelo pm entAcro nym UU Org . T yp eAcad em ic , T ra in in g a nd R ese arc h177120190620211029.pdfOrganizations20190620Page 4 Org aniz a tio n R ole Award ed O rg aniz a tio n Addre ss L in e 1 Prin ceto nla an 8 aAddre ss L in e 2 PO B ox80115Cit y T ow nUtr e chtSta te P ro vin ceUtr e chtCountr y NLDPosta l Z IP c o de3508 T C Web sit e http w ww.u u.n l c o pern ic usTw it te r H and le UUCopern ic us 177120190620211029.pdfOrganizations20190620Page 5 Pers o nnelIDFam ilyNam eFir s tOrg . A cro nymOrg . C it yOrg . C ountr yRole inConso rtiu mFundin g S ourc e15801Ghera rd iJe anneUVSQ L SC EGif s u rYvetteFra nceConso rtiu mLeadFra nce A N R15802Bla nchardAnneUiBBerg enNorw ayPartn er P INorw ay R C N 15808HuctinJe anMic helUVSQ O VSQ CEA RCGuyanco urtFra ncePartn er P IFra nce A N R15803Karls d ottirAnnaNORD REG IOSto ck ho lmSw ed enPartn er P ISw ed en F O RM AS15830Nik ulk in aIn gaNEFUYak uts kRussia n F ed era tio nth ePartn er P IRussia R FB R15805Van d erSlu ij sJe ro en P .UUUtr e chtNeth erla nd s th ePartn er P IThe N eth erla nd sN W O Conso rtiu m L ead G hera rd i, J e anne ID 1 5801Role in th e C onso rtiu m Conso rtiu m L eadFund in g A gency Fra nce A N R Fam ily N am e Ghera rd iFir s t N am es Je anneTit le s Dr. Em ail je anne.g hera rd i@ ls c e.ip sl. frPho ne +33760410767 Role in th e P ro je ct Pro je ct c o ord in ato r, in c harg e o f th e s c ie ntif ic c o ord in atio n, a nd p ro je ct m anagem ent. W P3 le ad er Prim ary O rg . UVSQ L SC E ID 1 5799Dep artm ent Obse rv ato ir e V ers a ille s S ain t Q uentinUnit L ab ora to ry LSC EPosit io n Asso cia te p ro fe sso r Are as o f R ese arc h [G eo chem is tr y , O cean s c ie nces, C lim ato lo gy] Hig hest A cad em ic Q ual. Docto ra l o r e q uiv ale nt le velYear O bta in ed P h.D . 2006 Prin cip al I n vestig ato r D eta ils Je anne G hera rd i w as a w ard ed h er P hD in c lim ate s c ie nces in 2 006. S he o bta in ed a M arie C urie I n tr a E uro peanpost d octo ra l fe llo w sh ip a t B je rk nes C ente r fo r C lim ate R ese arc h, B erg en, N orw ay. H er r e se arc h fo cus w asded ic ate d to a fu rth er u nd ers ta nd in g o f a tla ntic m erid io nal c ir c ula tio n c hanges w hic h c o uld h ave a fa r r e achin gim pact th ro ugh it s r o le in te le co nnectio n b etw een A rc tic a nd lo w la tit u d e r e gio ns. She o bta in ed a p erm anent p osit io n a s a sso cia te p ro fe sso r a t th e U niv ers it y o f V ers a ille s in 2 010 b ase d o n h erexp ertis e . I n 2 014 s h e to ok a 5 y ears le ave fr o m a cad em ic r e se arc h a s a p olic y o ffic er a t th e E uro pean a ndIn te rn atio nal A ffa ir s D ep artm ent o f I fr e m er. S he w as in vo lv ed in p ro je cts c o ord in atio n a nd m anagem ent o ftr a nsd is c ip lin ary H 2020 C oord in atio n a nd S up port A ctio n D AN CER S. S he r e p re se nte d I fr e m er a t v ario usnatio nal a nd in te rn atio nal p anel r e la te d to c lim ate a ctio ns C O P21, U N O cean c o nfe re nce, O cean a nd c lim atepla te fo rm . S he e xp erie nced s c ie nce d ip lo m acy a nd w ork ed in c lo se in te ra ctio n w it h F re nch E m bassie sM oza m bic , B angla d esh . S he h as th us a n e xte nsiv e p ra ctic e o f s ta k eho ld er c ente re d in te rd is c ip lin ary r e se arc h. Sin ce S ep te m ber 2 018, b ack to h er p erm anent a sso cia te p ro fe sso r p osit io n, s h e is r e o rie ntin g h er th em atic a re aof r e se arc h to w ard s tr a nsd is c ip lin arit y w it h a fo cus o n th e A rc tic r e gio n. S he is c o ord in atin g a tr a nsd is c ip lin aryhig hla tit u d e w ork in g g ro up w it h in th e P aris S acla y, a nd w ork in g c lo se ly w it h C EA RC la b ora to ry . 177120190620211029.pdfPersonnel20190620Page 6 Pub lic atio ns Burc k el P ., W aelb ro eck C ., L uo Y ., R oche D . M ., P ic hat S ., J a ccard S . L ., G hera rd i J . M ., G ovin A ., L ip poldJ., a nd T hil F 2 016. C hanges in th e g eo m etr y a nd s tr e ngth o f th e A tla ntic m erid io nal o vertu rn in g c ir c ula tio ndurin g th e la st g la cia l 2 0?50 k a. C lim ate o f th e P ast, 1 2, 2 061?2075. Lip pold J ., G hera rd i J . M ., L uo Y . 2 011. T estin g th e 2 31P a2 30T h p ale o cir c ula tio n p ro xy a d ata v ers u s 2 Dmodel c o m paris o n, G eo physic al R ese arc h L ette r, 3 8, L 20603 Ghera rd i, J . M ., L . L ab eyrie , S . N ave, R . F ra nco is , J . F . M cM anus, a nd E . C ortij o 2 009, G la cia l in te rg la cia lcir c ula tio n c hanges in fe rre d fr o m 2 31P a2 30T h s e d im enta ry r e co rd in th e N orth A tla ntic r e gio n,Pale o ceano gra p hy, 2 4, P A 2204, McM anus J . F ., F ra nco is R ., G hera rd i J . M ., K eig w in L . D . & B ro w nL eger S ., 2 004. C olla p se a nd r a p idre su m ptio n o f A tla ntic m erid io nal c ir c ula tio n lin k ed to d egla cia l c lim ate c hanges, N atu re , V 428, 8 348 37 Sta nic a A ., P anin N ., S chult z M ., C onsta ntin esc u A ., S crie ciu A ., G hera rd i J ., P ap ath anassio u V ., M ic halo poulo sP., G ajd use k F ., H ein T ., I rv in e K ., G ault J ., P ars o ns D ., D AN ub e m acro re gio n C ap acit y b uild in g a nd E xcelle ncein R iv er S yste m s b asin , d elt a a nd s e a T he K no w le d ge M atr ix d eliv era b le 2 .5 Oth er P ers o nnel R ep re se nte d None Partn er P I B la nchard , A nne ID 1 5802Role in th e C onso rtiu m Partn er P IFund in g A gency Norw ay R C N Fam ily N am e Bla nchardFir s t N am es AnneTit le s Dr. Em ail Anne.b la nchard @ uib .n oPho ne +47 5 5 5 8 2 1 4 7 Role in th e P ro je ct Lead er o f w ork p ack age 2 Prim ary O rg . UiB ID 1 5797Dep artm ent Facult y o f th e H um anit ie sUnit L ab ora to ry Centr e fo r th e S tu d y o f th e S cie nces a nd th e H um anit ie sPosit io n Rese arc her Are as o f R ese arc h [E nvir o nm enta l h ealt h , S ocia l p olic y] Hig hest A cad em ic Q ual. Docto ra l o r e q uiv ale nt le velYear O bta in ed P h.D . 2011 Prin cip al I n vestig ato r D eta ils Anne B la nchard w as a w ard ed h er P hD tit le d R efle xiv e in te rd is c ip lin arit y S up portin g d ia lo gue o n th e r o le o fsc ie nce fo r c lim ate c hange' in 2 011, a t th e U niv ers it y o f V ers a ille s S ain t Q uentin e n Y velin es F ra nce a nd th eUniv ers it y o f B erg en N orw ay, a s p art o f a n e xchange a gre em ent. S in ce th en, A nne h as b een b ase d a t th e C entr efo r th e S tu d y o f th e S cie nces a nd th e H um anit ie s U niv ers it y o f B erg en, N orw ay a s a p ost d octo ra l r e se arc herfir s t, a nd in a p erm anent r e se arc her p osit io n n o w . F ro m th e fie ld o f S cie nce a nd T echno lo gy S tu d ie s S TS, s h ehas a p artic ula r in te re st in fa cilit a tin g r e fle xiv e in te rd is c ip lin arit y in a c o nte xt o f e nvir o nm enta l a nd h ealt hgo vern ance, w it h in a fr a m ew ork o f R esp onsib le R ese arc h a nd I n no vatio n R RI. S he h as w ork ed in h ig hlyin te rd is c ip lin ary s e ttin gs, a nd ta k en p art in p ro je cts r a ngin g fr o m e lic it in g lo cal k no w le d ge o f c lim ate c hange inBangla d esh , to in te rro gatin g th e e th ic al a nd s o cia l a sp ects o f c ancer r e se arc h a t th e s c ie ncep olic y in te rfa ce. 177120190620211029.pdfPersonnel20190620Page 7 Pub lic atio ns Bre m er, S ., S tille r R eeve, M ., B la nchard , A ., e t a l. 2 018 C op ro ducin g P ost n o rm al C lim ate K no w le d ge w it hCom munit ie s in N orth east B angla d esh . W ea. C lim ate S oc., 1 0, 2 592 68 Bre m er, S ., B la nchard . A ., e t a l. 2 017 N arra tiv e a s a M eth o d fo r E lic it in g T acit K no w le d ge o f C lim ateVaria b ilit y in B angla d esh . W ea. C lim ate S oc., 9 , 6 696 86 Bla nchard , A ., H auge, K . H ., A nd ers e n, G ., F osså , J . H ., G rø sv ik , B . E ., H and egard , N . O ., e t a l. 2 014.Harm fu l r o utin es U ncerta in ty in s c ie nce a nd c o nflic tin g v ie w s o n r o utin e p etr o le um o pera tio ns in N orw ay. M arin ePolic y, 4 3, 3 133 20. Bla nchard , A ., & V and erlin d en, J . P . 2 013. P re re q uis it e s to in te rd is c ip lin ary r e se arc h fo r c lim ate c hangele sso ns fr o m a p artic ip ato ry a ctio n r e se arc h p ro cess in Î le d eF ra nce. I n te rn atio nal J o urn al o f S usta in ab leDevelo pm ent, 1 61 2 , 1 2 2. Bla nchard , A ., & V and erlin d en, J . P . 2 010. D is sip atin g th e fu zzin ess a ro und in te rd is c ip lin arit y th e c ase o fclim ate c hange r e se arc h. S .A .P .I .E N .S ., 3 1 , 1 6 . Oth er P ers o nnel R ep re se nte d Arja n W ard ek ker Partn er P I H uctin , J e anM ic hel ID 1 5808Role in th e C onso rtiu m Partn er P IFund in g A gency Fra nce A N R Fam ily N am e HuctinFir s t N am es Je anM ic helTit le s Dr. Em ail Je anm ic hel. h uctin @ uvsq .frPho ne +33 6 2 2 2 2 3 5 0 9 Role in th e P ro je ct Je anM ic hel H uctin w ill le ad W P1 a nd th e fie ld w ork in U um mannaq . H e w ill b e p art o f th e d aily m anagem entgro up . Prim ary O rg . UVSQ O VSQ C EA RC ID 1 5800Dep artm ent OVSQUnit L ab ora to ry CEA RCPosit io n Assis ta nt p ro fe sso r Are as o f R ese arc h [S ocia l w ork , S ocia l a nd c ult u ra l a nth ro polo gy, E ducatio n] Hig hest A cad em ic Q ual. Docto ra l o r e q uiv ale nt le velYear O bta in ed P h.D . 2016 Prin cip al I n vestig ato r D eta ils O ne o f th e fo und in g m em bers o f th e r e se arc h c ente r w hic h w as to b eco m e th e C EA RC "C ult u re s,Envir o nm ents , A rc tic , R ep re se nta tio ns, C lim ate " in 2 009 a t th e U VSQ . D evelo pm ent o f th e in te rn atio nal a nd m ult id is c ip lin ary M aste r o f A rc tic S tu d ie s, a g ra d uate p ro gra m w it h A rc ticstu d ents . P hD s tu d y 8 12 p ages in a nth ro polo gy, e th no his to ry a nd s o cio lo gy a t th e U niv ers it y o f P aris D id ero t a b out I n uitchild re arin g k no w le d ge a nd c hild m alt r e atm ent p ast a nd p re se nt, w it h a la rg e fo cus o n s o cia l w ork in G re enla nd . R ese arc h in te re sts in clu d e a ll fo rm s o f e d ucatio n, k no w le d ge c o pro ductio n b etw een I n d ig eno us a nd s c ie nces,clim ate e nvir o nm entc ult u re c hanges a nd s u sta in ab ilit y , fir s tly in G re enla nd , a ls o in C anad a a nd A la sk a. O ne o f th e e d it o rs o f th e in te rn atio nal e ncyclo ped ic s c ie nce b ook " G re enla nd . C lim ate , E co lo gy, S ocie ty " o nlyin F re nch fe atu rin g 1 00 a uth o rs , h e a ls o c o ntr ib ute d to th e p ub lis h in g in F re nch o f 4 h is to ric G re enla nd ic n o vels . P erio dic ally liv in g in U um mannaq G re enla nd 's W est c o ast s in ce 1 997. S peak k ala allis u t G re enla nd ic la nguage. J o in ed 1 0 d ogsle d e xp ed it io ns o n th e s e aic e d urin g m any y ears o f c o lla b ora tio n w it h th e U um mannaq C hild re n'sHom e. C ofo und atio n o f th e U um mannaq P ola r I n stit u te U PI, d ed ic ate d to o ffe rin g o rig in al c ult u ra l a ctiv it ie s to lo calyo ung p eo ple w hile p ro m otin g G re enla nd ic c ult u re . C ow rit e r a nd c o p ro ducer o f th e G re enla nd F re nch fe atu re film In uk '' 2 012. 177120190620211029.pdfPersonnel20190620Page 8 Pub lic atio ns K enned y G ., B erm an M ., G aye N ., H uctin J . M ., R aim onet M ., T ho m so n K . T ., V and erlin d en J . P ., 2 018.Envir o nm enta l H is to ry a nd th e C oncep t o f A gency I m pro vin g U nd ers ta nd in g o f L ocal C ond it io ns a nd A dap ta tio nsto C lim ate C hange in S even C oasta l C om munit ie s. G lo bal E nvir o nm ent. H uctin , J . M ., 2 018. I s si n uan' o u le r é co nfo rt d u fr o id u ne e xp érie nce th éra p eutic o é d ucativ e in uit s u r labanq uis e . L e fr o id , e d it e d b y D anie l C hartie r a nd J a n B orm . M ontr é al, P re sse s U niv ers it a ir e s d u Q uéb ec. B azta n J ., C ord ie r M . H uctin J . M ., Z hu Z ., V and erlin d en J . P ., 2 017. L if e o n th in ic e I n sig hts fr o mUum mannaq , G re enla nd fo r c o nnectin g c lim ate s c ie nce w it h A rc tic c o m munit ie s. P ola r S cie nce. M asso nD elm otte , V ., G auth ie r E ., G re m ille t D ., H uctin J . M ., S w in ged ouw D ., 2 016. L e G ro enla nd . C lim at,éco sy stè m es, s o cié té , P aris , C N RS É dit io ns 2 016. H uctin , J . M a nd A nd re ase n A ., 2 011. C hild re n o n th in ic e. I n te r N ord , n °2 1, e d it e d b y J e an M ala urie , C N RS,Paris . Oth er P ers o nnel R ep re se nte d Je anP aul V and erlin d en p ro fe sso r o f e nvir o nm enta l s tu d ie s a nd e co lo gic al e co no m ic s. Charlo tte D a C unha, A ssis ta nt p ro fe sso r in e co no m ic s a nd la nd u se p la nnin g. Partn er P I K arls d ottir , A nna ID 1 5803Role in th e C onso rtiu m Partn er P IFund in g A gency Sw ed en F O RM AS Fam ily N am e Karls d ottirFir s t N am es AnnaTit le s Senio r R ese arc h F ello w Em ail anna.k arls d ottir @ no rd re gio .o rgPho ne +46 7 35464872 Role in th e P ro je ct Exp ert o n n arra tiv e m eth o dolo gy, r e silie nce b uild in g, p artic ip ato ry m eth o ds, d em ogra p hic c hange a nd g end ereq ualit y Prim ary O rg . NORD REG IO ID 1 5796Dep artm ent Unit L ab ora to ry Posit io n Senio r R ese arc h F ello w Are as o f R ese arc h [In te rn atio nal r e la tio ns, G end er s tu d ie s, H um an a nd s o cia l g eo gra p hy] Hig hest A cad em ic Q ual. Docto ra l o r e q uiv ale nt le velYear O bta in ed P h.D . 2011 Prin cip al I n vestig ato r D eta ils Main p ro je cts w it h A nna K arls d ottir a s L ead P rin cip al I n vestig ato r L PI o r P rin cip al I n vestig ato r P I 2019 L PI fo r P ro je ct D EM O ? D em ogra p hic d evelo pm ent, G end er a nd s k ill s u p ply a nd c are r e sp onsib ilit ie s fo rth e fu tu re , fin anced b y N IK K, N ord ic G end er E qualit y F und 20172 020 L PI N ord ic T hem atic G ro up o n s u sta in ab le R ura l D evelo pm ent 20172 019 L PI P ro je ct o n R ura l P ers p ectiv es o f S patia l d is p arit ie s o f e d ucatio n a nd e m plo ym ent o utc o m es, 20152 017 L PI N ord ic A rc tic W ork in g G ro up s F ore sig ht S tu d y o n s u sta in ab le R egio nal D evelo pm ent in th eNord ic A rc tic s u p porte d b y N ord ic C ouncil o f M in is te rs E K R, 20132 020 P I O n th e M ove P artn ers h ip ? C anad ia n S H RC fu nd ed p ro je ct o n e m plo ym ent r e la te d g eo gra p hic almobilit y , 20142 021 P I N ORD RESS T he N ord ic C entr e o f E xcelle nce o n R esilie nce a nd s o cie ta l s e curit y , 20152 018 P I M ap pin g R esilie nce ? C oasta l C om munit ie s in I c ela nd fu nd ed b y I c ela nd ic R ese arc h F undR A N NIS , PI S A F21 S ocia l A sp ects o f F is h erie s fo r th e 2 1st c entu ry 2 0152 018, M arie C urie S klo dovsk a I T N . P IMobilit y to th e E dges o f E uro pe I c ela nd a nd P ola nd , fu nd ed b y E EA G RA N T 20132 016, P I E U F P7 fu nd ed E C O FIS H M AN 20112 014, P I S ocia l in d ic ato rs fo r A rc tic T ouris m in A rc tic O bse rv in g N etw ork ? S ocia l I n d ic ato r P ro je ct, N SFsu p porte d G ra nt N o. N SF O PP0638408 20082 011 P I G end er e q ualit y in n atu ra l r e so urc e m anagem ent in th e A rc tic ? W om en´s P artic ip atio n in D ecis io nMak in g P ro cesse s in A rc tic F is h erie s M anagem ent fu nd ed b y N orw egia n M in is tr y o f F ore ig n A ffa ir s a nd A rc ticCouncil S usta in ab le D evelo pm ent W ork in g G ro up . 177120190620211029.pdfPersonnel20190620Page 9 Pub lic atio ns Nils so n, A .E ., C ars o n, M ., C ost, D .S ., F orb es, B .C ., H aavis to , R ., K arls d ottir , A ., N ym and L ars e n, J ., P aasc he,Ø., S ark ki, S ., V am men L ars e n, S ., a nd P ely aso v, A . 2 019. P ro m is e s, c halle nges, a nd w ays fo rw ard fo rpartic ip ato ry s c enario m eth o dolo gie s in th e A rc tic , P ola r G eo gra p hy 4 23 Karls d óttir , A ., S m ed O ls e n, L ., G re ve H arb o, L ., J u ngsb erg , L , a nd R asm usse n, R .O . 2 017. F utu re R egio nalDevelo pm ent P olic y fo r th e N ord ic A rc tic F ore sig ht A naly sis 2 0132 016. N ord re gio R ep ort 2 0171 .Sto ck ho lm N ord re gio . Kokors c h, M ., K arls d óttir , A . & B ened ik ts so n, K . 2 015. I m pro vin g o r o vertu rn in g th e I T Q s y ste m V ie w s o fsta k eho ld ers in I c ela nd ic F is h erie s. M arit im e S tu d ie s. 1 41 5, 1 2 2. Karls d óttir , A . & J u ngsb erg , L . e d s. 2 015. N ord ic A rc tic Y outh F utu re P ers p ectiv es. C om mis sio ned fo r th eWork in g g ro up o n s u sta in ab le r e gio nal d evelo pm ent in th e N ord ic A rc tic . N ord re gio W ork in g p ap er 1 52 .Sto ck ho lm Fay, G . & K arls d óttir , A . 2 011. D evelo pin g a n A rc tic T ouris m O bse rv atio n S yste m . P ola r G eo gra p hy. 3 41 2 ,638 6 Oth er P ers o nnel R ep re se nte d Leneis ja J u ngsb erg , R ese arc h F ello w a t N ord re gio a nd P h.D . fe llo w a t C openhagen U niv ers it y Partn er P I N ik ulk in a, I n ga ID 1 5830Role in th e C onso rtiu m Partn er P IFund in g A gency Russia R FB R Fam ily N am e Nik ulk in aFir s t N am es In gaTit le s Pro f. D r. Em ail in ga1 23456@ yand e.r uPho ne +74 112 3 61 45 3 Role in th e P ro je ct Resp onsib le fo r W P4 a nd fie ld w ork im ple m enta tio n in T ik si. Partic ip atio n in th e p ro je ct o vera ll Prim ary O rg . NEFU ID 1 5811Dep artm ent Fin ancia l a nd E co no m ic I n stit u teUnit L ab ora to ry Dep artm ent o f E co no m ic s a nd F in ancePosit io n Pro fe sso r Are as o f R ese arc h [E co no m ic s, F in ance] Hig hest A cad em ic Q ual. Docto ra l o r e q uiv ale nt le velYear O bta in ed P h.D . 2018 Prin cip al I n vestig ato r D eta ils In 2 018, s h e d efe nd ed h er d octo ra l d is se rta tio n o n th e to pic « M eth o dolo gy o f d evelo pm ent o f bud geta ry , ta x a ndcusto m s m echanis m s fo r th e im ple m enta tio n o f s ta te fin ancia l p olic y in th e A rc tic z o ne o f th e R ussia n F ed era tio n». In 2 0132 015 p artic ip ate d a nd w as th e h ead o f th e in te rn atio nal r e se arc h p ro je ct o f th e R FB R « S tu d y o f c o asta lzo nes a d ap ta tio n to c lim ate c hange b ase d o n a n tr a nsd is c ip lI n ary a nd tr a nsn atio nal a p pro ach A RTIS TIC C»G 8_a R FFI G 8 F ound atio ns. I n 2 014, a s p art o f th is r e se arc h p ro je ct, s h e o rg aniz e d a nd p artic ip ate d in fie ldwork in T ik si, Y ak utia , R ussia . In 2 019, h e p artic ip ate s a nd is a c o ord in ato r in th e im ple m enta tio n o f a n in te rn atio nal r e se arc h p ro je ct c arrie d o utjo in tly b y N EFU a nd U VSQ p re p arin g a nd c o nd uctin g jo in t fie ld w ork in T ik si a nd B yk ovsk y, Y ak utia , R ussia as p art o f th e fir s t s ta ge o f th e la rg e s c ie ntif ic p ro je ct " N unata ry uk ." I n 2 019, I A SC G erm any r e ceiv ed a nin te rn atio nal g ra nt to c o ver re im burs e e xp ense s to a tte nd th e A SSW 2019 A rc tic S cie nce W eek S um mit , w hic hwas h eld fr o m M ay 2 2 to 3 0, 2 019 in A rk hangels k . The a uth o r h as p ub lis h ed 8 4 s c ie ntif ic p ap ers , in clu d in g 5 5 s c ie ntif ic p ub lic atio ns o n th e A rc tic to pic . T he a uth o rhas p ub lis h ed 4 m ono gra p hs 3 o f th em a re a uth o r's , 3 3 a rtic le s in p eer re vie w ed s c ie ntif ic jo urn als o f th e H ig herAtte sta tio n C om mis sio n u nd er th e M in is tr y o f E ducatio n a nd S cie nce o f R ussia . 177120190620211029.pdfPersonnel20190620Page 10 Pub lic atio ns Nik ulk in a, I ., G onchare nk o L . 2 018. T ax a nd c usto m s m echanis m s fo r r e gula tin g th e d evelo pm ent o f th e A rc ticzo ne o f th e R ussia n F ed era tio n fr o m th e s ta nd poin t o f s tr e ngth enin g n atio nal in te re sts . E co no m y. T axes. L aw . 6 ,1431 51. Nik ulk in a, I ., S uk neva S . 2 017. T ax M echanis m s o f E co no m ic D evelo pm ent a nd th e I m pro vem ent o f M ig ra tio nSit u atio n in th e R ussia n A rc tic . I n te rn atio nal J o urn al o f E co no m ic s a nd F in ancia l I s su es, 7 1 , 1 441 53. Nik ulk in a, I . 2 016. M eth o dolo gic al a p pro aches to fo rm atio n o f b ud geta ry a nd ta x a nd c usto m s m echanis m s o fin flu ence fo r s u p port z o nes o f d evelo pm ent o f th e A rc tic a nd th e s u p port p orts o f th e N orth ern S ea R oute .In no vativ e d evelo pm ent o f e co no m y, 6 3 6, 1 521 62. Nik ulk in a, I . S uk nyo va, S ., L uk ovts e va A . 2 014. T ax in str u m ents o f s tim ula tio n o f s m all b usin ess in d ig eno useth nic g ro up s o f th e R ussia n A rc tic . E co no m y. T axes. L aw , 6 , 1 111 15. Nik ulk in a, I . 2 014. B ud get a nd ta x m echanis m s fo r s u sta in ab le d evelo pm ent o f th e A rc tic z o ne o f th e R ussia nFed era tio n. E C O , 3 4 77, 1 151 24. Oth er P ers o nnel R ep re se nte d Ale xand er I s a ev E co lo gy Svetla na S uk neva D em ogra p hy Gord yachk ova O lg a E co no m ic s, d em ogra p hy Partn er P I V an d er S lu ij s , J e ro en P . ID 1 5805Role in th e C onso rtiu m Partn er P IFund in g A gency The N eth erla nd s N W O Fam ily N am e Van d er S lu ij sFir s t N am es Je ro en P .Tit le s Pro f. D r. Em ail j.p .v and ers lu ij s @ uu.n lPho ne +31 3 0 2 53 0 000 Role in th e P ro je ct Coord in atio n o f U U in te rv entio n Prim ary O rg . UU ID 1 5798Dep artm ent Copern ic us I n stit u te fo r S usta in ab le D evelo pm entUnit L ab ora to ry Envir o nm enta l S cie nces g ro upPosit io n Asso cia te p ro fe sso r Are as o f R ese arc h [In te rn atio nal s o cia l p olic y, O th ers in s o cia l s tu d ie s] Hig hest A cad em ic Q ual. Docto ra l o r e q uiv ale nt le velYear O bta in ed P h.D . 1996 Prin cip al I n vestig ato r D eta ils hIn d ex 5 3 G oogle S cho la r; 3 5 IS I W eb o f S cie nce m easu re d J u ne 2 019 4 p ap ers h ig hly c it e d to p 1 % ,Esse ntia l S cie nce I n d ic ato rs 2 018, 8 2 a rtic le s in p eer re vie w ed jo urn als a nd 2 9 b ook c hap te rs . My w ork o n u ncerta in ty in s c ie nce fo r p olic y a nd th e m eth o ds fo r k no w le d ge q ualit y a sse ssm ent th at I h avedevelo ped h ave a d vanced u nd ers ta nd in g o f d eep u ncerta in ty in s c ie ntif ic a sse ssm ent o f is su es s u ch a s c lim atechange a nd r is k s o f n ew a nd e m erg in g te chno lo gie s. I t h as in sp ir e d m any s c ho la rs a nd s c ie ncep olic y in te rfa cein stit u tio ns a ro und th e w orld a m ong th em th e N eth erla nd s E nvir o nm enta l A sse ssm ent A gency, th e E uro peanEnvir o nm ent A gency [ in vit e d c hap te r a uth o r o f 2 013 L ate L esso ns fr o m E arly W arn in gs I I r e p ort] , a nd th e U SEnvir o nm enta l P ro te ctio n A gency to d evelo p n ew w ays o f in te rfa cin g c o m ple x s c ie nce a nd p olic ym ak in g. I a mone o f th e le ad a uth o rs o f th e 2 019 S A PEA r e p ort M ak in g S ense o f S cie nce. I g uest e d it e d a s p ecia l is su e o fFutu re s v o l 9 1, 2 017 o n p ost n o rm al s c ie nce in p ra ctic e', b uild in g o n 2 in te rn atio nal c o nfe re nces th at I c o org anis e d . I a m a uth o r o f 4 c o rre sp ond ences in S cie nce 2 018 C all to r e str ic t n eo nic o tin o id s 5 x c it e d G oogleScho la r; 2 011 S cie nceP olic y I n te rfa ce B eyo nd A sse ssm ents , 6 3x c it e d G oogle S cho la r a nd N atu re 2 014Bio div ers it y r e p orts n eed a uth o r r u le s, 9 x c it e d ; 2 016 C lim ate c o stin g is p olit ic s, n o t s c ie nce 7 x c it e d . 177120190620211029.pdfPersonnel20190620Page 11 Pub lic atio ns Bre m er, S ., W ard ek ker, A ., D essa i, S ., S obolo w sk i, S ., S la atte lid , R ., a nd v an d er S lu ij s , J . 2 019. T ow ard amult i fa cete d c o ncep tio n o f c o p ro ductio n o f c lim ate s e rv ic es. C lim ate S erv ic es 1 3, 4 25 0. d oi10.1 016j.c lis e r.2 019.0 1.0 03. D.J . D ank el, N .S . V aage a nd J .P . v an d er S lu ij s 2 017 P ost N orm al S cie nce in P ra ctic e. F utu re s 9 11 4e d it o ria l s p ecia l is su e D O I1 0.1 016j.fu tu re s.2 017.0 5.0 09 M.M . H aq ue, S . B re m er, S .B . A ziz a nd J .P . v an d er S lu ij s 2 017 A c rit ic al a sse ssm ent o f k no w le d ge q ualit y fo rclim ate a d ap ta tio n in S ylh et D iv is io n, B angla d esh . C lim ate R is k M anagem ent 1 64 35 8.DO I1 0.1 016j.c rm .2 016.1 2.0 02 J.P . v an d er S lu ij s 2 017 T he N USA P a p pro ach to u ncerta in ty a p pra is a l a nd c o m munic atio n. C hap te r 2 9 p .3 01310 in C .L . S pash E d. R outle d ge H and book o f E co lo gic al E co no m ic s N atu re a nd S ocie ty . R outle gd e L ond on.IS B N 1 3 9 781 138931510. J.A . W ard ek ker, D . W ild sc hut, S . S te m berg er, J .P . v an d er S lu ij s 2 016 S cre enin g r e gio nal m anagem ent o ptio nsfo r th eir im pact o n c lim ate r e silie nce A n a p pro ach a nd c ase s tu d y in th e V enenV echts tr e ek w etla nd s in th eNeth erla nd s. S prin gerP lu s 5 7 50. D O I 1 0.1 186s 4 00640 162 408x Oth er P ers o nnel R ep re se nte d Dr. A rja n W ard ek ker, S enio r R ese arc her o n U rb an & R egio nal R esilie nce a nd C lim ate A dap ta tio n. U UCopern ic us I n stit u te , E nvir o nm enta l G overn ance g ro up . w ill s e rv e a s d aily s u p erv is o r o f th e p ostd oc, a nd a sWork P ack age le ad er fo r W P5. Postd oc v acancy th ro ugh th is p ro je ct . 177120190620211029.pdfPersonnel20190620Page 12 Bud get fo r P ro je ctTota l T im e R eq ueste d fo r P ro posa l162.0 M o.Tota l R eq ueste d F und in g fo r P ro posa l848.0 K ?Tota l E xte rn al F und in g fo r P ro posa l205.0 K ? Partn ers F und in g R eq uests Fundin g A gencyFundin gRequestFra nce A N R198.0Norw ay R C N 100.0Sw ed en F O RM AS150.0The N eth erla nd s N W O200.0Russia R FB R200.0 177120190620211029.pdfFunding Plan20190620Page 13 Pro je ct B ud get G hera rd i, J e anne, F ra nce A N RCate goryYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Tota lTim e d ed ic ate d to th is p ro je ct # m onth s9 9 9 0 27 M oSala rie s to ta l2020200 60 K ? P erm anen t s ta ff s a la rie s0 0 0 0 0 K ? N onp erm anen t s ta ff s a la rie s2020200 60 K ?Tra vel7 8 100 25 K ?Overh ead s1 1 2 0 4 K ?Consu m ab le s3 0 0 0 3 K ?Facilit ie s a nd e q uip m ent4 0 0 0 4 K ?Oth er in clu d in g s u b c o ntr a ct0 4 0 0 4 K ?Tota l r e q ueste d fu nd in g3533320 100 K ?Exte rn al fu nd in g s u p port2525250 75 K ? 177120190620211029.pdfFunding Plan20190620Page 14 Pro je ct B ud get B la nchard , A nne, N orw ay R C N Cate goryYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Tota lTim e d ed ic ate d to th is p ro je ct # m onth s4 2 2 0 8 M oSala rie s to ta l4020210 81 K ? P erm anen t s ta ff s a la rie s0 0 0 0 0 K ? N onp erm anen t s ta ff s a la rie s4020210 81 K ?Tra vel5 4 5 0 14 K ?Overh ead s0 0 0 0 0 K ?Consu m ab le s3 1 1 0 5 K ?Facilit ie s a nd e q uip m ent0 0 0 0 0 K ?Oth er in clu d in g s u b c o ntr a ct0 0 0 0 0 K ?Tota l r e q ueste d fu nd in g4825270 100 K ?Exte rn al fu nd in g s u p port0 0 0 0 0 K ? 177120190620211029.pdfFunding Plan20190620Page 15 Pro je ct B ud get H uctin , J e anM ic hel, F ra nce A N RCate goryYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Tota lTim e d ed ic ate d to th is p ro je ct # m onth s1212120 36 M oSala rie s to ta l2121110 53 K ? P erm anen t s ta ff s a la rie s0 0 0 0 0 K ? N onp erm anen t s ta ff s a la rie s2121110 53 K ?Tra vel9 9 6 0 24 K ?Overh ead s1 1 1 0 3 K ?Consu m ab le s0 0 3 0 3 K ?Facilit ie s a nd e q uip m ent5 0 0 0 5 K ?Oth er in clu d in g s u b c o ntr a ct0 5 5 0 10 K ?Tota l r e q ueste d fu nd in g3636260 98 K ?Exte rn al fu nd in g s u p port4040500 130 K ? 177120190620211029.pdfFunding Plan20190620Page 16 Pro je ct B ud get K arls d ottir , A nna, S w ed en F O RM ASCate goryYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Tota lTim e d ed ic ate d to th is p ro je ct # m onth s1010100 30 M oSala rie s to ta l3535350 105 K ? P erm anen t s ta ff s a la rie s2525250 75 K ? N onp erm anen t s ta ff s a la rie s1010100 30 K ?Tra vel5 108 0 23 K ?Overh ead s2 2 3 0 7 K ?Consu m ab le s0 0 0 0 0 K ?Facilit ie s a nd e q uip m ent0 0 0 0 0 K ?Oth er in clu d in g s u b c o ntr a ct5 5 5 0 15 K ?Tota l r e q ueste d fu nd in g4752510 150 K ?Exte rn al fu nd in g s u p port0 0 0 0 0 K ? 177120190620211029.pdfFunding Plan20190620Page 17 Pro je ct B ud get N ik ulk in a, I n ga, R ussia R FB RCate goryYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Tota lTim e d ed ic ate d to th is p ro je ct # m onth s1012120 34 M oSala rie s to ta l3036500 116 K ? P erm anen t s ta ff s a la rie s2327410 91 K ? N onp erm anen t s ta ff s a la rie s7 9 9 0 25 K ?Tra vel8 7 9 0 24 K ?Overh ead s8 8 7 0 23 K ?Consu m ab le s0 0 0 0 0 K ?Facilit ie s a nd e q uip m ent1 1 1 0 3 K ?Oth er in clu d in g s u b c o ntr a ct8 12140 34 K ?Tota l r e q ueste d fu nd in g5564810 200 K ?Exte rn al fu nd in g s u p port0 0 0 0 0 K ? 177120190620211029.pdfFunding Plan20190620Page 18 Pro je ct B ud get V an d er S lu ij s , J e ro en P ., T he N eth erla nd s N W OCate goryYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Tota lTim e d ed ic ate d to th is p ro je ct # m onth s8 109 0 27 M oSala rie s to ta l5161560 168 K ? P erm anen t s ta ff s a la rie s0 0 0 0 0 K ? N onp erm anen t s ta ff s a la rie s5161560 168 K ?Tra vel6 6 6 0 18 K ?Overh ead s0 0 0 0 0 K ?Consu m ab le s3 3 3 0 9 K ?Facilit ie s a nd e q uip m ent0 0 0 0 0 K ?Oth er in clu d in g s u b c o ntr a ct1 2 2 0 5 K ?Tota l r e q ueste d fu nd in g6172670 200 K ?Exte rn al fu nd in g s u p port0 0 0 0 0 K ? 177120190620211029.pdfFunding Plan20190620Page 19 Data M anagem entExp ecte d O utp uts The S eM PER A rc tic p ro je ct w ill p ro duce n ew in d iv id ual s u rv ey d ata , a p pro xim ate ly 2 55 0 in te rv ie w tr a nsc rip ts p er c o m munit y , th is c o verin g 3arc tic c o m munit ie s. T he a sso cia te d n arra tiv es w ill b e c o lle cte d u sin g s e m i s tr u ctu re d in te rv ie w p ro ced ure s, a s w ell a s r e se arc h a ctio n a nd p artic ip antobse rv atio n. T he tr a nsc rip ts w ill b e c o ded a gain st th e p ro je ct's id entif ie d r e silie nce p rin cip le s. D if fe re nt ty p e o f d ata w ill b e e xp lo it e d fr o mnarra tiv es, s c enario s, g ap a naly sis , in te rv ie w s, fo cus g ro up a nd o th er tr a nsc rip ts , to a rt fo rm s. P ub lis h ed d ata w ill b e e xp lo it e d in o rd er to c o nnectlo cal n arra tiv es to e xte rn al fo rc es a nd a sso cia te d s to rie s a nd s to ry lin es. W e a ls o a im a t p ro ducin g v is u als fo r a b ette r s h arin g o f th e m ult ip le s o urc esof k no w le d ge w e w ill b e m obiliz in g. D ata a nd g enera te d o utc o m e w ill b e u se fu l fo r a b ro ad a ud ie nce in clu d in g s c ie ntis ts , lo cal s ta k eho ld ers a nd th epub lic to b ette r a ncho r th e c o ncep t o f r e silie nce in th e a rc tic c o nte xt. Polic y C onfo rm anceMak in g d ata fin d ab le r e q uir e s th at th ey a re w ell d esc rib ed , id entif ie d a nd c ata lo gued . T his in clu d es a p pro pria te d efin it io n o f m eta d ata a ndkeyw ord s, s ta nd ard id entif ic atio n m echanis m s a nd n am in g c o nventio ns, a s w ell a s c re atio n o f s e arc hab le c ata lo gues. T he C EA RC r e se arc h c ente r,one o f th e S eM PER A rc tic p artn ers is c o ord in atin g p ro je cts th at a re d evelo pin g m eta d ata s c hem es fo r th e s to ra ge o f n arra tiv e tr a nsc rip ts .Colle cte d a nd g enera te d d ata w ill b e m ad e a ccessib le a d ju ste d to th e n eed s o f th e a ud ie nce, e .g . a s r a w d ata , a s fu rth er p ro cesse d a nd in te rp re te ddata , o r a s s u m mariz in g o verv ie w s o f r e su lt s . W here ver n arra tiv e d ata e nte r th e s c o pe o f th e G enera l D ata P ro te cte ctio n R egula tio n G DPR a ndcan th ere fo re n o t b e m ad e p ub lic , a ccessib ilit y o f m eta d ata w ill s till b e e nsu re d v ia s o m e s ta nd ard p ro to co l. I t w ill b e d ete rm in ed w heth erco m munit y b ase d m eta d ata s c hem es o r s ta nd ard s a re a vaila b le a nd if th ey c an b e a d opte d in o rd er to e nsu re in te ro pera b ilit y a nd r e u sa b ilit y . D atamust b e e asily id entif ia b le to e nsu re th at u se rs w ill fin d , a ccess a nd re u se th em . O ne o ptio n is to d ete rm in e n am in g c o nventio ns w it h in th eco nso rtiu m . B esid es th is , d ata s e ts w ill b e h allm ark ed b y p ers is te nt a nd u niq ue id entif ie rs s u ch a s D ig it a l O bje ct I d entif ie rs D O I. B y th is d ata s e tswill a ls o b e c it a b le , w hic h in cre ase s n o t o nly th e id entif ia b ilit y b ut a ls o th e v is ib ilit y . I n d efin in g m eta d ata fie ld s, e m phasis w ill b e p ut o n d atatr a ceab ilit y p ro venance a nd c o lle ctio n p ro ced ure a nd o n m eta d ata in te llig ib ilit y c la rit y , a ccura cy, c o m ple te ness. I f r e q uir e d , a c le ar d ata u sa gelic ense w ill b e m ad e v is ib le o n th e in te ra ctiv e w eb sit e a nd o n th e in te rfa ce to th e c entr a l d ata b ase a t th e c o ord in atin g p artn er's in stit u tio n s e e 1 3.4Outp ut P ro te ctio n. Open a ccess k no w le d ge s e e im pact a nd o utr e ach s e ctio n. Pla n P ers o nnelIn th e c o urs e o f th e p ro je ct, U VSQ C EA RC w ill h ir e o n a p art tim e b asis a p ro fe ssio nal d ata m anager, w ho h as e xp erie nce b oth in a tm osp hericphysic s d ata a nd s o cia l s c ie nce c o rp ora m anagem ent. J e anM ic hel H uctin a nd J e anP aul V and erlin d en, b oth te nure d fa cult y m em bers , w ill b ejo in tly r e sp onsib le fo r th e lo ngte rm m anagem ent o f th e d ata th at w ill b e g enera te d in th e c o urs e o f S eM PER A rc tic . Outp ut P ro te ctio nThe in te ra ctiv e w eb sit e d eliv era b le 7 .1 w ill b e d esig ned to b e s e am le ssly i a n in fo rm atio n p orta l fo r a ll in te re ste d a ud ie nces a nd ii a w ork sp aceth ro ugh r e str ic te d a ccess fo r c o nso rtiu m m em bers a nd p artn ers . T he r e str ic te d a ccess s e ctio n w ill b e th e d ata s h arin g a re a th at th e p ro je ctmem bers w ill u se in th e c o urs e o f th e p ro je ct a nd b efo re tr a nsfe r to th e in stit u tio nal fa cilit y o f th e c o ord in atin g p artn er s e e b elo w 1 3.5 . A p art tim epro fe ssio nal d ata m anager w ill b e p art o f th e te am a nd h as b een b ud gete d fo r. Post P ro je ct D ata M anagem entAll d ata w ill b e d ep osit e d o n a d ed ic ate d r e p osit o ry a t th e c o ord in atin g p artn er's in stit u tio n. Each p artn er w ho g enera te s d ata r e m ain s o w ner o f th e d ata , y et r e sp onsib ilit y fo r s to ra ge a nd a ccessib ilit y , a s d esc rib ed in th e G ra nt A gre em entand th e C onso rtiu m A gre em ent, is th e r e sp onsib ilit y o f th e c o ord in atin g p artn er U VSQ . U VSQ is p art o f a la rg er c o nso rtiu m o f u niv ers it ie s,Univ ers it é P aris S acla y, w hic h is c urre ntly d evelo pin g th e p ro ced ure s fo r lo ngte rm d ata s to ra ge h ttp s w ww.u niv ers it e p aris sa cla y.fr fr le sdonneesd ela re cherc he. S eM PER A rc tic w ill th us b enefit fr o m th is in stit u tio nal s e t u p a nd w ill u se it s g uid ance to id entif y a lo ngte rm d atare p osit o ry . T he o utp ut w ill b e p ub lis h ed w it h a D O I. Restr ic tio nsThe r e str ic tio ns th at w ill b e e nfo rc ed a re th o se a sso cia te d w it h th e e th ic al g uid elin es fo r r e se arc h in vo lv in g h um an s u b je cts . I n fo rm ed c o nse nt w ill b ere q uir e d a b out th e id entif ic atio n o f d ata u se rs a nd u sa ge. A p ro ced ure fo r u sa ge e xte nsio n w it h o ut c re ep w ill b e d evelo ped a cco rd in g to th eco nso rtiu m m em bers ' r u le s a nd r e gula to ry e nvir o nm ent e nvir o nm enta l r e gula tio ns. Pre se rv atio n o f R estr ic tio nsWhere ver n arra tiv e d ata in clu d e e le m ents th at fa ll in th e s c o pe o f th e G enera l D ata P ro te cte ctio n R egula tio n G DPR a nd c an th ere fo re n o t b emad e p ub lic , th ese d ata w ill b e d eta in ed b y th e d ata c o lle cto r in a s e cure d in stit u tio nal a rc hiv e. A ccessib ilit y o f n o nse nsit iv e d eriv ed p ro ducts e .g .su m marie s a nd m eta d ata w ill s till b e e nsu re d s e e 1 3.4 O utp ut P ro te ctio n. Docum enta tio n a nd M eta d ata fo r R euse 177120190620211029.pdfData Management20190620Page 20 Meta d ata w ill b e a ccessib le th ro ugh a n o nlin e s e arc hab le c ata lo gue s e e 1 3.2 P olic y C onfo rm ance. D ata c o lle ctio n p ro to co ls w ill b e p ub lis h ed a spro je ct d ocum ents a nd w ill b e r e fe rre d to in th e m eta d ata . T he p ro je ct fin al r e p ort w ill in clu d e in fo rm atio n o n th e d ata a nd m eta d ata a rc hiv es,in clu d in g th e lin k to th e m eta d ata c ata lo gue. LongT erm S up port C osts The h o m e in stit u tio ns o f th e c o ord in atin g p arty h ave b een e ngaged in s u ch a ctiv it ie s fo r m any y ears , th e r e currin g c o sts o f d ata m anagem ent a re p artof th eir o rd in ary y early b ud get. 177120190620211029.pdfData Management20190620Page 21 Pro posa l E le m entsEle m entFileExecutiv e S um mary1771e xecutiv eS um mary _ 14S Em PER A rc tic _ E xecutiv e_ su m mary F in al. p dfPro je ct D esc rip tio n1771d esc rip tio n_ 15S Em PER A rc tic _ P ro je ct_ desc rip tio nF in al. p dfManagem ent P la n1771m anagem entP la n_ 16S Em PER A rc tic _ M anagem ent_ P la nF In al. p dfIm pact, E ngagm nt, a nd D is s. P la n1771c o m munic atio n_ 17S Em PER A rc tic _ Im pact _ and _outr e achF in al. p dfExte rn al F und in g1771e xte rn alF und in g_ 18S Em PER A rc tic _ E xte rn al_ F und in gF in al. p dfFund in g J u stif ic atio n1771fu nd in gJu stif ic atio n_ 19S Em PER A rc tic _ F und in g_ ju stif ic atio nF in al. p dfRefe re nces C it e d1771re fe re ncesC it e d _20S Em PER A rc tic _ R efe re nces_ cit e d F in al. p dfSup portin g L ette rs1771su p portin gL ette rs _ S up port_ L ette r_ S eM PER A rc tic .p df177120190620211029.pdfAttachments20190620Page 22 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 1 3 14. Executive summary Rooting its work in the Arctic, with and for Arctic communities, the ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ project consortium will be collecting local stories of changes, shocks, upheavals and their aftermaths. The SeMPERArctic team members will adopt these narratives as local, and localized, anchoring devices for resilience analysis. Members of three Arctic communities have been involved in the preparation of SeMPERArctic Uummannaq, on the west coast of Greenland, Ittoqqortoormiit on the east coast of Greenland and Tiksi in the Republic of Sakha. SeMPERArctic consortium has committed to work with and for these communities. Their stories of individual and collective ability to face shocks, threat, unusually fast changes, will constitute SeMPERArctic central corpus. The SeMPERArctic research project is relying on three working hypotheses 1. Arctic settlements who have experienced, recent or less recent, important environmental, demographic, economic, or social, upheavals needed high levels of resilience in order to face the associated shocks > working hypothesis #1 if lessons are to be learned for Arctic communities, then they are to be learned from arctic communities. 2. When confronted to such shocks and the associated changes, community members, as individuals, and local communities, as collectives, made sense of it in the light of their own knowledge, beliefs and experiences > working hypothesis #2 making sense of shocks leads to identityanchoring narratives that are intertwined with the conditions for resilience. 3. These conditions for resilience are identifiable within local narratives by bridging local science with the concept of resilience through systembased thinking, resilience principles used as design guides and evaluation criteria, and the associated pragmatic approach to resilience analysis> working hypothesis #3 systembased resilience analysis allows for a respectful bridging of community knowledge and external knowledge. The SeMPERArctic consortium will be reframing these narratives by singling out selfidentified sources of strength and weaknesses with a focus on concepts that emerged form preparatory fieldwork in the three partner communities ¥ sense making; ¥ place attachment; and ¥ extended networks acting as, or contained within, nonlocal institutions. 177120190620211029.pdfExecutive Summary20190620Page 23 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 2 3 The intertwined natureculture historical depth of local narratives will be respected; connection with nonarctic interpretations of changes will be established; the bridging of local narratives with external narratives will be achieved through the application of systembased thinking principles of resilience. Lessons from arctic communities will be learned and made available to be shared widely. While preparing SeMPERArctic with arctic communities members, and through desktop analysis, the SeMPERArctic project, two broad categories of narratives that are external to communities have been identified as priority area of enquiry. These are centered on a environmental science; and b public policy and regional development. The SeMPERArctic consortium will analyze how these narratives interact with local narrative of resilience. This will allow for the assessment of their actual or potential impacts. Using this narrative centered approach, the SeMPERArctic project team will build an interdisciplinary framework of resilience interpretations. This framework will be used to closely examine the resilience narratives as collected and analyzed in the light of the dimensions that are salient to for the members of arctic communities. The SeMPERArctic consortium will thus be in a position to take stock of the lessons learned in its three pilot implementation sites. The SeMPERArctic consortium will have developed a narrative centred, locally rooted, placebased understanding of resilience within arctic communities. This understanding is key for developing tools and strategies to increasing community resilience in other communities. These results will call for sharing the lessons learned within SeMPERArctic with regional planners and policymakers. The SeMPERArctic consortium will thus be contributing to the knowledge base on global environmental change through respectful, nonprejudiced, enquiry of what it means to be a resilient arctic community in the 21st century. ÒResilienceÓ in the Arctic will be analysed as the interplay with external forcings of LOCAL nature, culture, history, environment and knowledge NOT as the product of any Òrandomly appliedÓ western dominant paradigm. The results of this analysis will be translated into options for actions, at the local, regional, national and circumpolar levels. The SeMPERArctic consortium groups scientists from France, the Nederland, Sweden, the Russian Federation and Norway. These scientists come from a variety of complementary disciplinary fields climate science, regional sciences, planning, anthropology, economics, science and technology studies, environmental studies, ecology, and demography. The SeMPERArctic project is the product of longstanding relationships and science codevelopment with the population and stakeholder from the case study sites. The SeMPERArctic project has been designed for a threeyear duration. SeMPERArctic is organized with 4 transverse work packages WP1, WP2, WP5, WP6, 2 thematic work 177120190620211029.pdfExecutive Summary20190620Page 24 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 3 3 packages WP3, WP4 and will be deployed in three arctic communities. A more functional work package WP7 will take care of project management, coordination and outreach activities. The transverse work packages are arctic centred integration exercises dealing with data collection WP1, postcolonial science making WP2, integration WP5 and impact maximisation WP6. The thematic work package are mobilizing current scientific knowledge on the external and internal forces that we envision as central to the framing and interpretation of the local narratives in terms of resilience climate science WP3 and regional development and public policy analysis WP4. 177120190620211029.pdfExecutive Summary20190620Page 25 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 1 16 15. Project description 15.1 Background 15.1.a Resilience as a polysemic concept and the associated risks. Since its widespread deployment, the concept of resilience has been used for a diversity of applications. This diversity led to a diversity of meanings. This can form a challenge to the utility and conceptual integrity of resilience as policy concept cf. Kaplan, 2005. This diversity and its consequences must be carefully taken into account when using the concept in intercultural, postcolonial, or colonial, contexts. Exploring resilience in the Arctic calls for a clear understanding of the conceptÕs history and associated diversity and plasticity e.g. Alexander 2013, Barroca et al. 2013, Kane and Vanderlinden 2015. Meerow et al. 2016 stress the fact the definition of resilience Òmight serve as a boundary object, with the acknowledgement that applying resilience in different contexts requires answering Resilience for whom and to what When Where And whyÓ Wardekker 2016, 2018, in press show that resilience is ÔframedÕ in diverging ways, connected to different goals, values, policy options, knowledge & analytical approaches, and mechanisms of what makes a system or community resilient Ôresilience principlesÕ. This has important implications for how resilience is built De Boer et al. 2010; Wardekker et al. 2010, and whether and how communities can learn from each other Ilgen et al. 2019. Mobilizing resilience thus implies comparing different situations. Resilience is a concept that contains the necessity to make judgements and thus to choose who is entitled to make such judgements. The SeMPERArctic consortium members believe that, when it comes to arctic communities, they are entitled to these judgements. 15.1.b A narrative turn for resilience analysis ÒPeople express, develop, and model their identity, and even their future actions, through narrationÓ Moezzi et al. 2017. This quote captures how narratives may encapsulate the interplay of identity and action. Yet narratives are not only at the juncture of identity and action, they are also the concrete manifestation of the fabric that allow for the existence of communities narratives are the carrier of the sharing of experience, values, contexts that community members have in common Rommetveit et al. 2013. Narratives are also the carriers of the various meaning associated to the concept of resilience Kane and Vanderlinden 2015. For instance, Janif et al. 2016 used local narratives to analyse how these might be used to inform effective and sustainable adaptation strategies to climate change in peripheral Fiji communities. In their case, narratives are more than ÒcarriersÓ of identity and action; they 177120190620211029.pdfProject Description20190620Page 26 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 2 16 are carrier of the knowledge that gives to communities the ability to cope in adversity, i.e. resilience through the stabilization of identity. The SeMPERArctic consortium members consider that narratives are more than carriers of identity, including traditional knowledge, and action, as performatives. The SeMPERArctic consortium members consider that narratives contain the seeds, through localized experience, of genuinely local manifestations of resilience. These manifestations and the associated conditions is what we are set to gather with and for Arctic communities. The SeMPERArctic consortium will thus simultaneously capture stories of change and coping, judgement made comparing situations, and the meaning that individuals associated to the actions, or inactions, the narratives contain. 15.1.c Three current blind spots in resilience analysis a sense making, b place attachment and c extended networks In order to prepare the SeMPERArctic project, consortium members conducted scoping work in Ittoqqortoormiit, Uummannaq and in the Sakha republic fieldwork conducted in April and May 2019 in Greenland and in June 2018 in the Sakha Republic. We also revisited corpuses collected in Tiksi reanalysis conducted in April and May 2019 of a series of interview transcripts. The aim of these scoping exercises was threefold 1 making sure that there is local interest for the work the SeMPERArctic consortium that will be conducive of resilience science codevelopment; 2 seeing whether collecting narratives was actually possible; and 3 somehow taking stock of priority themes that might emerge from these visits and revisits. Three recurring themes emerged a sensemaking, b place attachment and c extended networks. Furthermore, these appeared as connecting devices between local experience and external forces, resilience to short term shocks and resilience in the face of long term change, and, between the local community and external communities. Sense making when confronted to changes, community members, as individuals, and local communities, as collectives, make sense of it in the light of their own knowledge, beliefs and experiences. Communities' sensemaking of changing institutional et natural environments can be defined as the interaction between their own frame of reference and the perception of the situational demands that are inherent to changes, and their interpretation of these changes. Such dynamic sensemaking constantly redefines the boundaries of the narratives that community members may mobilize to give meaning to their past, their present, and their future. Yet this sensemaking process is deeply influenced by frame of references that are the product of communities that are external to local arctic communities. Science, and the scientific community, are important carrier of such Ònew,Ó Òexternal,Ó frame of references. 177120190620211029.pdfProject Description20190620Page 27 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 3 16 Place attachment place attachment appears as one of the central drivers of arctic communitiesÕ fight to fend of external and internal sources of stress. Place attachment refers to bonds that people develop with places, bonds that are multidimensional, evolve through time, and have been documented and analyzed for quite some time Giuliani, 2003. When conducting the SeMPERArctic preparatory fieldwork, interviewee mentioned their attachment to their community as a powerful motivation to face stress, to rebound in case of shock. In times of changes, place attachment is identified, for instance, as a determinant of the decision to outmigrate as an adaptation strategy Heleniak 2009. Place attachment is also identified as a strong identity marker Dixon and Durrheim, 2004. Place attachment may also be seen as the integration of multiscale connections connection to those we hold dear, connection to our community and connection to the environment, connection to our ancestors who lived and died and are buried there Raimond et al. 2010. This is of key importance to resilience as well. Socioecological resilience definitions indicate that resilience is Òthe capacity of a system to absorb disturbance and reorganize while undergoing change so as to still retain essentially the same function, structure, identity, and feedbacksÓ Walker et al., 2004. For arctic communities, place attachment is directly connected to their identity, structure and feedbacks. It is an important determinant in how they interpret and value shocks and change Ð if they erode place attachment, they erode the community and its resilience. Environmental and policy changes narratives may reframe the way community members understand these connections. The SeMPERArctic consortium will analyze these dimensions. Extended networks one of the consequences of the urban concentration in the Arctic is the rise of geographically extended networks of individual. For these individuals, their place of origin remains of central importance when defining who they are, who they interact with, and where they turn to in times of duress. Furthermore these ÒdiasporasÓ are of critical importance when it comes to negotiating access to urban centered infrastructures, health services and other manifestations of the external world. These extended networks thus have a central importance when situation of stress call for external intervention. Our working hypothesis is that they appear in resilience narratives and do connect community level narratives, with science based narratives of global change or development centered narratives. 15.1.d Arctic science on narratives While the SeMPERArctic project call for a narrative turn in resilience research, narrative analysis has already been practiced in the arctic; it has most likely already influenced the framing of narrativebased and centered enquiries. Local arctic narratives of change have become widely studied, and in so doing, the scientific community mediates these narratives see among many instances Cruikshank 2000, Prokkola 2007, Stammler 2013, Veland and 177120190620211029.pdfProject Description20190620Page 28 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 4 16 Lynch 2017, and Wexler 2009. When mobilized, narratives are reinterpreted through scientific frames of resilience and adaptation, and retold anew. Conceivably, this can change the way communities and places are represented both from the outside and from within. From the outside, local narratives are combined and reconfigured into narratives of global change, used within international climate change sciencepolicy networks. Narratives lose their specificity, with implications on how communities are viewed by others. From within local communities, the scientific retelling of their narratives can influence how people make sense of social and natural changes around them, and the evolving ideas of place that come with these changes. Seen as such, the scientific mediation of local narratives can be seen as a challenge of postcolonial times. At the same time, there is value in the careful and respectful study of local narratives, i where they can offer transferable lessons on adaptation and ii where the scientific retelling may make local communities more mindful of changes previously unobserved. This introduces one of the important research questions that the SeMPERArctic consortium will address How does scientific research represent local arctic narratives of change Answering, even partially to this question, will facilitate reflexivity when collecting and analyzing local narratives of resilience. It has thus been included into SeMPERArctic research plan. 15.1.e Competing narratives that exist Òout thereÓ Local narratives are central to the analysis that is proposed. Their treatment calls for an understanding of their influences, locally and externally. Yet one must also take into account competing external narratives. There is a necessity to identifying these competing narratives , and to understand their interactions with local narratives of resilience. While preparing SeMPERArctic with arctic community members, and through desktop analysis, the SeMPERArctic project two broad categories of narratives have been identified as priority area of enquiry. These are centered on a environmental sciences; and b public policy and regional development. The Òenvironmental scienceÓ narrative Numerous studies and reports have illustrated the drastic changes occurring in the Arctic ACIA, and evolution of different climatic indicators for instance Cappelen 2001, Box 2002, Box et al.2019. Most of the studies tend to give a global overview of changes in the geographical Arctic, and takes earth systems sciences on the Arctic and global concern about the Arctic as the premise for a sciencesociety interface Bravo 2009. However, it has been demonstrated that those sciences narratives do not necessarily resonate with the local community interests Baztan et al 2017, Bravo 2009. These narratives, that comes as alternative to the local communityÕs may have unforeseen influences. Local narratives draw strength from local meaningfulness, so their association with an external scientific community could dilute their integrity, thus eroding resilience enhancing identity see Janiff et al. 2016. Furthermore, considering SeMPER Arctic working 177120190620211029.pdfProject Description20190620Page 29 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 5 16 hypotheses sense making may be influenced through the multiplication of interpretative frames; place attachment may be influenced through the changing representations that community members may have of the ecological integrity of their living environment; and the very nature of network and of what makes them stand the test of time may be influenced through the mere hosting of scientists and the social reconfigurations that this may entail. In SeMPERArctic we will dig into the existing literature and datasets to extract available dataset which saliency will be established directly through the use of the communitiesÕ narratives. The Òpublic policy and regional developmentÓ narrative much is written concerning the economy of arctic communities, their development, quality of life, and demographic potential. As subsistence economies remain important, a first narrative stream is associated to the ability of local population to capture ecosystem services and the associated knowledge a thematic review of ecosystem services in the arctic may be found in Malinauskaite et al. 2019, an archetypical example of ÒecosystemservicescumlocalknowledgeandpolicymakingÓ narrative may be found in Tesar et al. 2016. Yet arctic sustainability involves taking into account the features and specifics of the main components of arctic economies in a broader sense Gad and Strandsbjerg 2018. This has led to the development of broader narratives, rooted in History. For instance, the end of the Soviet Union and the associated development of an indigenous market led to deep transformation of local livelihoods. Another example of narrative associated to development centered goal is the one that is carried by policies that seems to encourage urbanization in Greenland. Regional development policies tell stories of arctic communities, their future, what they are what they should or might be. These narratives connect to and thus influence local narratives of resilience. In SeMPERArctic we will explore these connections and analyze the interplay of these ÒdevelopmentÓ narratives with local narratives in terms of sensemaking, place attachment and extended networks. 15.1.f Integrating these perspectives on resilience Above, we highlighted that Arctic resilience is seen through different narrative lenses, particularly linguistics, natural science, regional development & politics. We will also examine resilience in different case study sites. We have outlined a device, the SeMPERArctic project, to articulate, join, narratives from within communities and from without. This multitude of perspectives calls for an integration. In order to achieve this integration, the SeMPERArctic consortium will address the following critical integrative questions what are the differences and similarities in resilience interpretations among the lenses and cases What are the consequences of these for developing an integrated, inter and transdisciplinary perspective on enhancing arctic resilience 177120190620211029.pdfProject Description20190620Page 30 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 6 16 What overarching lessons might we learn for Arctic resilience How might Arctic communities learn or be hindered from learning due to differences in the situation & interpretation from each other in terms of resilience To do so, the SeMPERArctic project team will build an interdisciplinary framework of resilience interpretations. The literature shows different approaches to resilience in different literatures e.g. Brand & Jax, 2007; Davidson et al., 2016; Cote & Nightingale, 2012; Wardekker, 2016, 2018, in press; Moser et al., 2019. Different interpretations may emphasize different Ôresilience principlesÕ that describe or improve resilience Wardekker, 2016, 2018, in press. Resilience principles describe specific mechanisms that make a system resilient or that help policies and practices enhance that resilience Wardekker, 2018. Examples include buffer capacity, redundancy, high flux, compartmentalization, systems thinking, access to resources, and strong local identity. An advantage of using such principles is that they can be related to described reasons for shocks and changes, reasons for why a system was or wasnÕt resilient, and policy options that might be promoted. Therefore, an interdisciplinary framework of resilience principles, spanning multiple perspectives, can be easily connected to local narratives. In the SeMPERArctic project, we will apply this framework to closely examine the resilience narratives as collected and analyzed in the light of the dimension that are presented above in the text. We will be in a unique, robust, culturally respectful, position to describe similarities and differences across the analytical lenses, and across the cases. We will also examine changes in perspective over time, within each case. Drawing on this analysis, we aim to synthesize the lessons learned with respect to a the state and improvement of resilience in arctic communities through the actual resilience practices of arctic communities, and b how different perspectives on resilience interact and might fruitfully interact in the Arctic. 15.1.f Arctic resilience science, narratives, and the need to engage into action, the need to maximize impact All the development that are presented above lead to a necessity. The necessity to be in a position to share these analyses, once the SeMPERArctic consortium will be in a position to take stock of its three pilot implementation sites. The SeMPERArctic consortium will have developed a narrative centred, locally rooted, placebased understanding of resilience within arctic communities. This understanding is key for developing tools and strategies to increasing community resilience in other communities. These results will call for sharing the lessons learned within SeMPERArctic with regional planners and policymakers. What is more, transferring experiences and good practices of citizen and community resilience across local, regional and national planners can further uncover innovative solutions and 177120190620211029.pdfProject Description20190620Page 31 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 7 16 tools to address some of the most pressing challenges. It can also lead to a more inclusive governance system that builds on placebased experiences and best practices ensuring resilience in the longrun. Furthermore, these results and stories will be anchored into business development strategies related to the tourism sector. Arctic communities have abundant and unique cultural heritage that can be capitalised on this heritage is exactly what the stories we will be collecting is about. Personalised storytelling in combination with the unique landscapes in the Arctic can attract visitors bringing new opportunities to the region while protecting and promoting the cultural heritage of its communities. Ultimately, sustainable tourism could increase peopleÕs awareness of climate change on the livelihood of communities in the region as well as those outside it. Community narrative would then be the influencers, their experience would be the source of lesson for the outside world. Within SeMPERArctic, a unique partnership with the Arctic Business Council, a Greenlandic indigenous organisation, will allow for the organization of a series of workshops translating SeMPERArctic data and results into local economic development plans for sustainable tourism. These workshops will identify actions that can be taken to create local and regional resilience enhancing development. The composition of participants with different backgrounds and from different communities will create a foundation for crosscommunity learning for building resilience locally. 15.2 Research plan 15.2.a Rationale of research plan and overarching organization SeMPERArctic is organized with 4 transverse work packages WP1, WP2, WP5, WP6, 2 thematic work packages WP3, WP4 and will be deployed in three arctic communities. A more functional work package WP7 will take care of project management, coordination and outreach activities. The transverse work packages are arctic centred crosscutting exercises dealing with data collection WP1, postcolonial science making WP2, integration WP5 and impact maximisation WP6. The thematic work package are mobilizing current scientific knowledge on the external and internal forces that we envision as central to the framing and interpretation of the local narratives climate science WP3 and regional development and public policy analysis WP4. This work plan has also been designed to develop and test the SeMPERArctic approach in pilot sites in the Arctic; i Uummannaq, on the west coast of Greenland; ii Ittoqqortoormiit, on the east coast of Greenland, and iii Tiksi on the Laptev sea in northern Siberia see section 15.3.c. 177120190620211029.pdfProject Description20190620Page 32 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 8 16 15.2.b Work packageWP list WP Title Content Total effort PM Leader 1 Collecting narratives of resilience Method development, narrative collection and initial coding 30 UVSQCEARC JM Huctin 2 Reflexivity in narrativebased resilience science Current practice in the collection of arctic narrative, reflexivity devices, postcolonial and colonial context 12 UiBSVT A Bremer 3 Environmental sciencebased narratives Scientific analysis of environmental change within the pilot communities 18 UVSQLSCE J Gherardi 4 Development narratives Regional development policies and their influence 30 NEFU I Nikulkina 5 Integration and progress on arctic resilience Arctic integrated resilience model. 21.4 UUCopernicus UiBSVT A Wardekker 6 Taking stock of SeMPERArctic results to engage into action. Conditions for sharing, business applications, and resilience enhancement tool. 20 Nordregio L Jungsberg 7 Project coordination and outreach activities Robust coordination of the project and outreach activities. 30 UVSQLSCE J Gherardi 177120190620211029.pdfProject Description20190620Page 33 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 9 16 15.2.d Work package descriptions Workpackage 1 Collecting narratives of resilience lead UVSQCEARC WP number 1 WP title collecting and organizing data on local instances of actual resilience Leader UVSQCEARC Start date Month 1 End date Month 36 Partners & involvement PMs UVSQCEARC 18 UVSQLSCE 0 NEFU 12 Nordregio 0 UiBSVT 0 UUCopernicus 0 Objectives Collecting the narratives and coding them against Sensemaking, place attachment, extended networks Activities Task 1.1 Methodological development and pretesting of methods Task 1.2 Collection and organization of narratives Task 1.3. Preliminary coding of te narratives; Deliverables D1.1 Report describing the method to collect and analyze SeMPER Arctic foundational data comprehensive data collection package for each site appended led by UVSQCEARC, with all partners, delivery month M6 D 1.2Database containing the corpora that have been collected led by UVSQCEARC, with all partners, delivery month M12 D1.3 Coded narratives within a Atlas.ti hermeneutic unit and accompanying analysis report. led by UVSQCEARC, with all partners, delivery month M18 Milestones M1.1 Protocol for the production of D1.1 UVSQCEARC, M 2 M1.2 terms of reference for D1.2 UVSQCEARC, M 8 M1.3 Protocol for the production of D1.3 available online UVSQCEARC, M 13 177120190620211029.pdfProject Description20190620Page 34 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 10 16 Work package 2 Reflexivity in narrativebased resilience science WP number 2 WP title Toward reflexive narrativebased resilience science Leader UiBSVT Start date Month 1 End date Month 36 Partners & involvement PMs UVSQCEARC 0 UVSQLSCE 0 NEFU 0 Nordregio 0 UiBSVT 3 UUCopernicus 9 Objectives Setting the necessary conditions to conducting resilience centered science and narrative collection in the north while taking into account the challenges of postcolonial and colonial contexts. Activities Task 2.1 review the scientific representations of local narratives in the Arctic. This review will be undertaken both through a desktop study of published material including grey literature and interviews with selected practicing researchers working with local communities, as key informants. Task 2.2 nurturing of the reflexivity within the SeMPERArctic consortium This task will support the consortium members when they will be facing questions such as how do we ourselves change local narratives by studying them How can we exercise care and responsibility with regard to narratives Deliverables D2.1 manuscript of a paper analyzing scientific representations of local narratives. It will be accompanied by a concise communication to be published openaccess on a platform widely read by the science and policy community, ideally in Nature Communications or One Earth. led by UiB SVT, with CopernicusUU, delivery month M20 D 2.2 report taking the form of a diary about a series of reflexive discussions that will be held with the SeMPERArctic consortium at each consortium meeting led by led by UiB SVT, with CopernicusUU, delivery month 34 Milestones M2.1 First iteration of the ÒReflexivity Diary shared with the consortium members. UiB SVT, M12 M2.2 Outline and protocol for the production of D2.1 UiB SVT, M16 M2.3 second iteration of the ÒReflexivity Diary shared with the consortium members. UiB SVT, M24 177120190620211029.pdfProject Description20190620Page 35 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 11 16 Work package 3 Environmental sciencebased narratives. WP number 3 WP title Narratives of changing environments what does climate and ecological sciences tell us Leader UVSQLSCE Start date Month 1 End date Month 36 Partners & involvement PMs UVSQCEARC 0 UVSQLSCE 10 NEFU 8 Nordregio 0 UiBSVT 0 UUCopernicus 0 Objectives Catalogue and analyze the available environmental science and data as they relate to local issues. Activities Task 3.1 review the existing historical environmental archives in the 3 communities prioritizing the dimensions appearing in the narratives collected in WP1 and adopting a reflexive posture following the work of WP2, Task 3.2 establishing the linkages between scientifically observed environmental changes and the concepts of sense making, place attachment and extended network. Deliverables D3.1 Local environmental synthesis and chronology for Uummannaq, Ittoqqortoormiit and Tiksi, taking into account local saliency criteria and its accompanying comparative overview paper. led by UVSQLSCE, delivery month M12 D 3.2 Coding report ÒsynchronizingÓ local narratives of resilience with environmental sciences using issues of sense making, place attachment and extend networks as syncing devices. led by UVSQLSCE, delivery month M24 Milestones M3.1 Catalogue of available information and preliminary listing of saliency criteria. UVSQLSCE, M9 M3.2 Outline and protocol for the production of D3.2 UVSQLSCE, M18 177120190620211029.pdfProject Description20190620Page 36 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 12 16 Workpackage 4 Regional development and policies narratives WP number 4 WP title Regional development and policies narratives Leader NEFU Start date Month 1 End date Month 36 Partners & involvement PMs UVSQCEARC 6 UVSQLSCE 0 NEFU 11 Nordregio 13 UiBSVT 0 UUCopernicus 0 Objectives Catalogue and analyze the regional development and policy narratives as they relate to local narratives in terms of sense making, place attachment, and extended networks Activities Task 4.1 review and analyze the various regional development policies that have influenced the three case studies communities. Task 4.2 establishing the linkages between scientifically observed environmental changes and the concepts of sense making, place attachment and extended network. Deliverables D4.1 Identification of salient regional policies and analysis in terms of community level saliency criterion and its accompanying comparative overview paper. led by NEFU, delivery month M12 D4.2 Coding report ÒsynchronizingÓ local narratives of resilience with the analysis of regional policies using issues of sense making, place attachment and extend networks as syncing devices. led by NEFU, delivery month M24 Milestones M4.1 Catalogue of local saliency criteria in terms of regional policies. NEFU, M6 M4.2 Outline and protocol for the production of D4.2 NEFU, M18 177120190620211029.pdfProject Description20190620Page 37 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 13 16 Workpackage 5 Integration and progress on arctic resilience WP number 5 WP title Integration and progress on arctic resilience Leader UiBUU Start date M 1 End date M 36 Partners & involvement PMs UVSQCEARC 3 CNRS LSCE 0 NEDFU 0 Nordregio 0 UiB SVT 3 CopernicusUU 15.4 Objectives Integrate the observed issues, trends, and lessons learned through WP1 to 5 multitude of perspectives Activities Task 5.1 Interdisciplinary framework of resilience interpretations ¥ devising an interdisciplinary framework of resilience interpretations, using resilience principles from different literatures. Task 5.2 Integrated analysis of arctic narratives of resilience. ¥ applying the interdisciplinary framework of resilience interpretations to closely examine the resilience narratives as described in WP1,3,4. Deliverables D5.1 Framework for analyzing resilience narratives, based on resilience principles led by SVTUiB, with CopernicusUU and CEARCUVSQ, delivery month M9 D 5.2 Manuscript for a scientific article with detailed background report on the application of the D5.1 framework on resilience in arctic communities led by SVTUiB, with all consortium members, delivery month M24 D5.3 Manuscript for a position paper for both a scientific and policy journal on fruitful interaction of arctic and noarctic perspectives on resilience led by SVTUiB, with CopernicusUU and CEARCUVSQ, delivery month M34 Milestones M5.1 terms of references for D5.1 UiBUU, M6 M5.2 Outline and redaction plan of D5.2 UiBUU, M12 M5.3 Outline and redaction plan of D5.3 UiBUU, M18 177120190620211029.pdfProject Description20190620Page 38 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 14 16 Work package 6 Impact maximization WP number 6 WP title Impact maximization Leader Nordregio Start date M 1 End date M 36 Partners & involvement PMs UVSQCEARC 6 CNRS LSCE 0 NEFU 0 Nordregio 14 UiB SVT 0 CopernicusUU 0 Objectives Mobilize the results to engage into experiments to increase SeMPERArctic impact. Activities Task 6.1 Developing and analyzing the condition for data and results sharing.. Task 6.2 Developing and experimenting a business model for tourism development grounded in local narratives. Task 6.3 Developing a resilience enhancement tool. Deliverables D6.1 Research paper on the conditions for very localized results and data sharing with policy makers led by Nordregio, with CEARCUVSQ, delivery month M 18 D 6.2 Report on the development of narrative centered resilience enhancing tourism operations led by Nordregio, with CEARCUVSQ, delivery month M 24 D6.3 Practical resilience enhancement tool targeted at local communities, regional development officer and policy maker M 34 Milestones M6.1 Outline and redaction plan for D6.1 Nordregio, M9 M6.2 Outline and redaction plan of D6.2 Nordregio, M12 M6.3 Specifications of the resilience enhancement tool D6.3 Nordregio, M20 WP7 Coord., dissemination and outreach This work package is described in the management plan section. 177120190620211029.pdfProject Description20190620Page 39 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 15 16 15.3 Competence and expertise; complementarities of consortium; interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary approaches; global geographical diversity 15.3.a Complementarities of the consortium The SeMPERArctic consortium groups scientists of various disciplinary background, expertise, age, gender, nationality. It is coordinated by a climate scientist who expanded her practice to transdisciplinary studies of climate change and its impacts Gherardi, UVSQLSCE. It comprises researcher with expertise in regional sciences and planning Jungsberg, Karlsdottir, Nordregio , economics Nikulkina, NEFU, Vanderlinden, UVSQCEARC, science and technology studies scholars Blanchard, van der Sluijs, Wardekker, UiB SVTand UUCopernicus, ecology Isaev, NEFU, demography Sukhbnova, NEFU. Hiring will be done in order to further diversify the consortium. Most consortium members have been working on other projects with at least one other partner institution and most often with two to three. The complementarity of the team is the product of interactions that the consortium members have already experienced. 15.3.b Interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary approaches This project will traverse a variety of social science and humanities disciplines, and demands explicit attention to interdisciplinary practices and technologies, and reflexivity on how we conduct scientific studies. Consortium members Dr. Blanchard and Prof. Vanderlinden have extensive experience and expertise in nurturing reflexive interdisciplinary dynamics Blanchard and Vanderlinden, 2010, 2012, 2013, Da Cunha and Vanderlinden 2014, Vanderlinden et al., 2012, 2015, including through dedicated activities to be employed at consortium meetings. This project will benefit from these activities. Some of these are described in the management plan. Reflexivity will also come from reflexive sessions as part of work package 2. 15.3c Global geographical diversity The three pilot case studies are a central device of SeMPER Arctic research plan. They are bringing the highestlevel diversity that could be achieved considering the characteristics of the SeMPERArctic project. In order to further manage the high risks associated to SeMPERArctic innovative approach, site selection was voluntarily limited. Because of the groundbreaking nature of the plan ahead, a conscious choice was made to conduct these three pilot case studies in locations where team members have been working in the past. These are location where partnership have already proved to be solid and based on mutual respect. The appended support letter demonstrates, if necessary, the reality and quality of these relationships. A brief description of the three pilot communities follow. Uummannaq is an island of 12km2 and a fjord, located in the middle of the West coast of Greenland. Today, the biggest challenge for this community is to find a way to remain a 177120190620211029.pdfProject Description20190620Page 40 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 16 16 sustainable and attractive community in spite of the demographic urban concentration, in the south, economic globalization and the need of rationalization to build the country's future independence. Climate changes cause dramatic impacts on landscapes and people. The key feature that led us to select Uummannaq lies in its vulnerability, explained by history, combined with current challenges associated with far reaching climate and policy changes. Ittoqqortoormiit is a community at the eastern tip of Greenland. Founded in 1925, Ittoqqortoormiit has long relied on subsistence hunting as its main source of livelihood. The community was prosperous until the fall of the hides market, but is now under pressure. It remains rather isolated, 930km away from Tasiilaq, and access remains weather dependent. Tourism is seen as one of the only economic options. Tiksi is, according to many, RussiaÕs northernmost town. As such, it is going through major transformations associated to climate change ranging from the melting of the permafrost to increased shipping due to increasing accessibility of the NorthEast Passage. Yet, since the end of the Soviet Union, Tiksi has been facing a dramatic reduction of its economic activity and population. It has since a very large part of its employment base, and many see its future as quite unpromising. As a study site, Tiksi brings lessons to be learned from a fragile community that has fared and is still faring through major sources of stress. 177120190620211029.pdfProject Description20190620Page 41 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 1 8 16. Management plan 16.1 Overall coordination, monitoring and control of the project The management of the project will be part of WP7, ÔProject management, outreach and dissemination of resultsÕ. This task will be led by the project coordinator LPI, UVSQLSCE, with all participants being involved along the lines described below. 16.1.a Management structure The overall project will be coordinated by the Lead Principal Investigator, Jeanne Gherardi, who has considerable experience participating into the design and management of international projects. Furthermore, Jeanne Gherardi has served as internal project development officer in one of France major research institution. She will be assisted in her task by a core ÒDaily management group,Ó a ÒPartner Assembly,Ó a ÒManagement BoardÓ and ÒSiteSpecific Committees.Ó Details of the components of the management structure, identified in Figure 1, are given below, together with the specific roles and responsibilities of individuals associated with each group. In summary i the Daily management group will be composed of the projectÕs coordinator assisted by two colleagues from the same institution both with important and complementary experience in project management and coordination Vanderlinden and Huctin and by the UVSQ administrative and financial management officer that will be assigned to the project. This group will organize all the activities and of the project and will report on a monthly basis to the Management board. ii the Partner Assembly is the primary decisionmaking body for the project; it will comprise one representative of each partner institution and will be chaired by the LPI; it will meet formally at the end of each project retreat every 11 months; iii the Management Board will be the supervisory body ensuring a successful execution of the project; it will comprise the task leaders and be chaired by the LPI; it will meet facetoFigure 1 SeMPERArcticÕs governance. 177120190620211029.pdfManagement Plan20190620Page 42 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 2 8 face at the beginning of each project retreat every 11 months, and regular every 1 month conference calls will be held to follow up on progress; iv the SiteSpecific Committees will be the local bodies where local fieldwork coordination and stakeholder involvement will occur; they will consist of the scientists involved locally in fieldwork implementation, plus a panel of local endusers governmental and nongovernmental. They will be chaired by the PI associated with the site; they will meet regularly during intensive fieldwork periods and will report to the Management Board every month. 16.1.b Scientific coordination The overall scientific coordination will be the responsibility of the project coordinator and Management Board see above. In order to conduct its coordination tasks, the Management Board will hold regular meetings through teleconferencing at least every month, and a facetoface meeting at the beginning of each project retreat. The purpose of these meetings will be to ensure regular progress within each task and field setting, to identify and address any emerging issue and to validate work plans for the upcoming period. Central milestones of SeMPERArctic scientific coordination are its regular retreats. Every 11 months, two members or associates of each partner institution and, whenever possible, two representatives of local users, will join in a sciencefocused 4day retreat followed immediately by a Partner Assembly meeting. These retreats will be designed to maximize crossfertilization between institutions, disciplines and study sites while minimizing the risk of having partners moving along separate pathways. The envisioned retreat are the following. Retreat 1 organizer UVSQ, Greater Paris area Month 3 Retreat 2 organizer Nordregio, Stockholm area or location of Belmont meeting Month 15 Retreat 3 organizer NEFU, Yakutsk or location of Belmont meeting Month 27 Retreat 4 and final ÒResilience science for and with arctic communitiesÓ conference organizer UVSQ, location to be identified we will aim proactively at combining this retreat with another event Month 36 While these retreats will be critical moments for the projectÕs scientific coordination. Coordination will also be sustained through the proactive use of webbased communication, including a specifically designed web space and monthly video conferences. 177120190620211029.pdfManagement Plan20190620Page 43 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 3 8 16.1.c Critical path and risk management Tables 1 lists the deliverables of the project chronologically. Care has been taken to identify critical informationsharing situations that will be placed on the webinar and or Management Board meeting agenda. Table 1 Chronological list of scientific deliverables D and milestone M Number Title Month of delivery Leader M1.1 Protocol for the production of D1.1 2 UVSQCEARC D1.1 Report describing the method to collect and analyze SeMPER Arctic foundational data comprehensive data collection package for each site appended 6 UVSQCEARC M4.1 Catalogue of local saliency criteria in terms of regional policies. 6 NEFU M5.1 Terms of references for D5.1 6 UiBUU M1.2 Terms of reference for D1.2 8 UVSQCEARC M3.1 Catalogue of available environmental science information and preliminary listing of saliency criteria 9 UVSQLSCE D5.1 Framework for analyzing resilience narratives, based on resilience principles 9 SVTUiB, with CopernicusUU M6.1 Outline and redaction plan for D6.1 9 Nordregio D 1.2 Database containing the corpora that have been collected 12 UVSQCEARC M2.1 First iteration of the ÒReflexivity Diary shared with the consortium members 12 UiB SVT D 3.1 Local environmental synthesis and chronology for Uummannaq, Ittoqqortoormiit and Tiksi, taking into account local saliency criteria and its accompanying comparative overview paper 12 UVSQLSCE D4.1 Identification of salient regional policies and analysis in terms of community level saliency criterion and its accompanying comparative overview paper. 12 NEFU 177120190620211029.pdfManagement Plan20190620Page 44 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 4 8 M5.2 Outline and redaction plan of D5.2 12 UiBUU M6.2 Outline and redaction plan of D6.2 12 Nordregio M1.3 Protocol for the production of D1.3 available online 13 UVSQCEARC M2.2 Outline and protocol for the production of D2. 16 UiB SVT D1.3 Coded narratives within a Atlas.ti hermeneutic unit and accompanying analysis report 18 UVSQCEARC M3.2 Outline and protocol for the production of D3.2 18 UVSQLSCE M4.2 Outline and protocol for the production of D4.2 18 NEFU M5.3 Outline and redaction plan of D5.3 18 UiBUU D6.1 Research paper on the conditions for very localized results and data sharing with policy makers 18 Nordregio M6.3 Specifications of the resilience enhancement tool D6.3 20 Nordregio, D2.1 Manuscript of a paper analyzing scientific representations of local narratives, accompanied by a concise communication to be published openaccess 20 UiB SVT M2.3 Second iteration of the ÒReflexivity Diary shared with the consortium members 24 UiB SVT D 3.2 Coding report ÒsynchronizingÓ local narratives of resilience with environmental sciences using issues of sense making, place attachment and extend networks as syncing devices. 24 UVSQLSCE, D4.2 Coding report ÒsynchronizingÓ local narratives of resilience with the analysis of regional policies using issues of sense making, place attachment and extend networks as syncing devices. 24 NEFU D5.2 Manuscript for a scientific article with detailed background report on the application of the D5.1 framework on resilience in Arctic communities 24 SVTUiB D6.2 Report on the development of narrative centered resilience enhancing tourism operations 24 Nordregio D 2.2 Report taking the form of a diary about a series of reflexive discussions that will be held with the SeMPERArctic consortium at each consortium meeting 34 UiB SVT 177120190620211029.pdfManagement Plan20190620Page 45 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 5 8 D5.3 Manuscript for a position paper for both a scientific and policy journal on fruitful interaction of arctic and noarctic perspectives on resilience 34 SVTUiB D6.3 Practical resilience enhancement tool targeted at local communities, regional development officer and policy maker 34 Nordregio The first element of risk for SeMPERArctic lies in delays and miscommunications at critical moments during the project. Given the structure of SeMPERArctic, these critical moments lie at the articulation between the various work packages. WP1 will be centered on the identification, organization and analysis of narratives its outputs will be used by the whole project. WP2 will develop conditions for a reflexive postcolonial practice of narrative centered resilience research. The output of WP2 will also be used within the project as a whole. WP5, and WP6, as integrative WPs will need outputs from all WPs. Furthermore WP3, 4 and 5 will iteratively use the outputs of all WPs in order to conduct their analysis. Failure is not an option for any of the WP if the project is to achieve its objectives. Furthermore, all WPs need to be finely articulated. In order to manage the risks of poor WP performance or the risks of poor crossWP articulation, the SeMPERArcticÕs retreats are critical. Although conference calls and webinars will be intensively used to manage the risk inherent to the complex and ambitious SeMPERArctic project, facetoface interactions and sustained collective work sessions are critical for the success of interdisciplinary work. The focus of these retreats will include preparing the way forward for the next 11month period this preparation will entail presenting the results of upstream tasks and focusing on proactively ensuring crosstasks and crosssites synergies. To follow the progress of these milestones, Ôupcoming milestoneÕ will be on the agenda of each Management Board monthly conference call. In this way, unforeseen difficulties will be addressed promptly. A third element of risk is the possibility that a consortium member is unable to fulfil its obligations. In such situation, the Management Board will enter in communication with the scientific officer through the LPI, in order to recommend a course of action to the Partner Assembly. However, this risk will be minimized by the development of a robust Consortium Agreement containing at least the following elements i the distribution of the tasks, human and financial resources and deliverables, as well as the related timings; ii the sharing of the intellectual property rights linked to findings obtained within the framework of the project; iii the project start and end dates; iv the conditions for publication dissemination of the results; and v the application and transfer of project finding. 177120190620211029.pdfManagement Plan20190620Page 46 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 6 8 16.1.e Description of WP7, Project outreach and coordination WP number 7 WP title Outreach and coordination Leader UVSQLSCE Start date Month 1 End date Month 36 Partners & involvement PMs UVSQCEARC 3 UVSQLSCE 17 NEFU 3 Nordregio 3 UiBSVT 2 UUCopernicus 2 Objectives Ensuring the project success through robust and transparent management, allowing the project to reach out to nonparticipants. Description of activities Task 7.1 Organization of projectÕs meeting lead UVSQLSCE with hosts Task 7.2 Development of information pack and web space lead Nordregio, with all; Task 7.3. Development of training curriculum lead UVSQCEARC with all; Task 7.4 crosscutting tasks Ensure that ethics in research and considerations of gender balance and gender perspectives are integrated in all work packages lead UVSQLSCE; Task 7.5 Organization and follow up of projectÕs scientific and financial reporting lead UVSQLSCE Expected results and deliverables D7.0 Consortium agreement signed by all partners. D7.1 a to d meeting reports led by UVSQLSCE, all partners, delivery two weeks after meeting D 7.2 Web space running and functional led by Nordregio, delivery month M 2 D7.3 information booklets are produced and assembled 6 for WP, 3 for sites month 18 led by Nordregio M 15 D7.4 Online curriculum and training material available led by UVSQCEARC, delivery month M33 D7.5 Three videos documenting the deployment of SeMPERArcticÕs results mediation artwork. D7.6 a, b mid term and final reports led by UVSQLSCE months 20 and 38. 16.2 Open Knowledge plan SeMPERArcticÕs activities lead to three levels of planning of open access knowledge. The first level is the management of the data generated within SeMPERArctic from narratives, scenarios, gap analysis, interviews, focus group and other transcripts, art forms etc. The second level is the lessons learned throughout the implementation of SeMPERArctic. The third level is concerned with the access to the scientific results and associated publications. These three levels will be addressed by using the framework and recommendations given in 2015 by the JPI climate Sancho Reinoso and Helgenberger, 2015. These are All SeMPERArctic partners will have access to all the material produced; a confidentiality agreement will be drawn up in order to grant access to nonpublic material see Ôethical guidelinesÕ below. 177120190620211029.pdfManagement Plan20190620Page 47 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 7 8 All public deliverables and public material will be licensed, using creative commons licensing CC0, inasmuch as this is possible when considering intellectual property rights, particularly concerning the art forms that will be produced as a result of the project. The use of open formats, i.e. ODF e.g. *.odt, *.ods, *.odp for working documents will be strongly encouraged, to allow for broad compatibility; all publicly available material will use open formats; SeMPERArcticÕs research results will be published either through i Open Access journals, books or proceedings i.e. ÔgoldÕ Open Access or ii selfarchiving of subscriptionbased formats including embargoes i.e. ÔgreenÕ Open Access. Open access publishing costs have been included in the budget request. 16.4 Climatefriendly research Particular attention will be given to limiting SeMPERArcticÕs activitiesÕ contribution to greenhouse gas emissions. The following have already been Ð or will be Ð taken into account limiting the number of facetoface meetings, by using longdistance communication conference calls, webinars, webbased workspace as much as possible; organising SeMPERArctic retreats in locations that a many as possible may reach by train Obiously the Arcticness of SeMPERArctic may somehow limit the possibilities on this front; choosing climatefriendly venues for the projectÕs retreats; use, when rational and authorized, compensation mechanism, for cases when air travel is directly connected to the success of the project. 16.3 Research ethics considering the involvement of human subjects The work involves very little risk and nuisance to the participant outside of the time dedicated to short interviews and focus group. These will be dovetailed inasmuch as possible into already existing activities. In order to minimize disruption, the interview and focus groups will be organized according to the schedule befitting to the participants. Field level work and restitutions will be conducted in the language of the case study communities. Informed consent related information will be communicated ex ante, orally and in writing to potential participants, in the language of the study site. The informed consent information will clearly spell out the nature of their participation, the type of information SeMPERArctic researcher will be eliciting. Their freedom not to participate will be clearly expressed as well as the burden loss of time and benefit that SeMPERArctic may entail. All local and national applicable legislations will be respected. Through SeMPERArcticÕs team established partnership we do have access to information of local regulatory context. 177120190620211029.pdfManagement Plan20190620Page 48 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 8 8 All the collected material Ð i.e. focus group corpuses, interview recording and transcripts, videos Ð will be made available through our open knowledge strategy. All consortium members will follow all ethical guidelines and rules associated with research in their respective host institutions. We will systematically implement informed consent statement that includes freedom of participation and withdrawal, analysis of risk to subjects, description of the anonymization procedure and the description of data safeguarding. For all case study the work being conducted relies on wellestablished local relationship, dwelling on mutual respect and history. 177120190620211029.pdfManagement Plan20190620Page 49 Implementation Plan 2019 Document 03 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II 1 6 17. Impact, engagement and dissemination plan 17.1 expected impacts The SeMPERArcticÕs participatory action research science coconstruction transdisciplinary approach leads to three types of expected impacts 1 identifications of local actions for the resilience enhancement of the local communities we will be working in; these, and the associated lessons learned from the implementation of SeMPERArctic, will feed into the production of 2 2 guidance resources for research actions that takes into account the specifics of arctic communities resilience; the whole process allowing for the production of 3 3 a series of transdisciplinary scientific productions furthering the knowledge on communitylevel resilience in the Arctic. In order to maximize these impact the SeMPERArctic consortium has devised a specific Wprk PackageP, WP6 geared at exploring ways to optimize impacts, including dovetailing our results with private tourism operators. 17.1.a Local actions for a local SeMPERArctic legacy The resilience science coconstruction process that has been engaged with the preparation of the SeMPERArctic project aims, locally, at having positive impacts for the communities that will participate into the project. This positive impacts are centered on the understanding that Tiksi, Ittoqqortoormiit and Uummannaq community members will be in a better position to act on resilience enhancing dimensions of their identity. Community leaders will be in a position to assess some of the changes they are facing in terms of environmental changes, policy changes, and extensions of the communitiesÕ networks. Furthermore, the proactive connection of external scientific knowledge with local, known, and newly documented, situations of actual resilience, will allow for the establishment of renewed scientific partnerships. Such a partnership will be focused on the desires and needs of the community. In these three pilot communities the SeMPERArctic project has thus the high potential of being a starting point for locally driven science geared at bettering local conditions in the face of global change. Finally, the SeMPERarctic consortium had engages into a privileged relationship with one of the emerging local tourism sector. The dovetailing of SeMPERarctic data and results as support tool for tourism development will be experimented in all three communities. The associated lessons learned will be shared with the scientific community D6.2 and with local resilience actors D7.xx.. 177120190620211029.pdfImpact, Engagement, and Dissemination Plan20190620Page 50 Implementation Plan 2019 Document 03 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II 2 6 17.1.b Guidance resources on Arcticcentered resilience research action a wider SeMPERArctic legacy These guidance resources will take the form of pragmatic webbased material. A suite of groundtested protocols and procedures for identifying Arctic communitiesÕ needs in terms of resilience analysis will be made available. This resilience analysis protocols will be rooted in the communitiesÕ daily scheme of things and will take the form of a resilience enhancement tool D6.3 most likely a series of hierarchized check list each item referring to online explanation as to why the item matters and how it manifested itself in the pilot study sites. Lessons learned in the codevelopment and testing of this tool will be integrated into the foreseen training curriculums deliverable 7.4 targeted at resilience developer, resilience knowledge brokers and resilience knowledge producers. This curriculum will be entitled ÔImproving ArcticÕs resilience by using arctic communitiesÕ experiences in overcoming adversity.Õ This SeMPERArctic training material will be the product of the integration of the following key project outcomes a robust, groundtested procedure to capture local narratives in their dynamic dimensions as they pertain to local experiences of resilience; a robust groundtested procedure and associated protocols for taking into account the central role of sensemaking, place attachment and extended networks for the purpose of maintaining or increasing the resilience of arctic communities; a robust groundtested procedure and associated protocols for reconciling community level narratives with externally driven science ; an integrative webbased training curriculum allowing for the application of SeMPERArcticÕs development in other arctic sites. The availability of this training material and its proactive promotion means that this expected impact of SeMPERArctic is the possibility for resilience development officers, users and brokers to apply the SeMPERArctic approach in different situations where local communities are confronted with the multidimensional challenges associated with climate change and all changes. The mere application of SeMPERArcticÕs tools is not the only expected impact. The training material will also pragmatically embody the lessons the SeMPERArctic consortium has learned during the project. Resilience knowledge users, brokers and producers will thus be in a position to use this ÔtoolboxÕ to feed their thinking on their actions at the local level. These two dimensions of SeMPERArctic potential impacts will improve the ability of information producers to address communitiesÕ climate information needs. Although promising, such potential impacts are particularly challenging in terms of user engagement. 177120190620211029.pdfImpact, Engagement, and Dissemination Plan20190620Page 51 Implementation Plan 2019 Document 03 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II 3 6 SeMPERArctic has thus been structured so that the proposed research will have the maximum positive impact on those who have a stake in the resilience of arctic communities. 17.1.c a series of transdisciplinary scientific productions furthering the growth of our epistemic community the science centered SeMPERArctic legacy Knowledgebased social innovations occur within and through epistemic communities and communities of practice see Haas, 1992; Paavola et al., 2004; Cohendet et al., 2001; Wenger 1998 that potentially constitute an important part of an extended peer community. To foster the growth of these communities we will use 3 traditional and novel means within SeMPERArctic. First, we will ensure that final project results are freely available to the scientific community, and we will when possible acceptable opt for open access publishing gold access. Sometimes it might be appropriate to opt for restricted access journals e.g. when publishing in a special issue; in such cases we will ensure archiving in an online repository and provide access through personal websites green open access. To further disseminate the project results to a wider scientific community, the peer network of the communities associated with the highly interdisciplinary SeMPERArctic consortium will be used, as well as relevant working groups and conferences. Second, the scientific results conceptual, methodological, peerreviewed publications will be accompanied by notes describing the nature of the results in language appropriate to the various categories of potential interested parties. All this will be made available on the projectÕs web space, with links to the papers or documents. Third, during the meetings and workshops, the issue of building and addressing new communities will be discussed and the interaction with existing communities will be reviewed and adapted if necessary. This will allow for constant improvement of SeMPERArcticÕs societal impact and outreach mediated by the arctic resilience, resilience and arctic science communities. Finally, local environmental changes and status related to each study sites will synthesized in peerreviewed journals and made available in a dedicated format to each communities. 17.2 Dissemination and exploitation of resultscommunication plan 17.2.a Information pack The first set of measures to disseminate and exploit SeMPERArctic results will be the development of an information pack containing central elements of the project and designed to grow progressively as the project proceeds and generates results. This package will take the form of printed leaflets Ð one presenting the project as a whole, and one per work package and one per study site deliverables D7.3 a to h. This material will be distributed within the consortium membersÕ and endusersÕ networks as well as to the press. The impact of this material will be reinforced by the availability of an interactive website 177120190620211029.pdfImpact, Engagement, and Dissemination Plan20190620Page 52 Implementation Plan 2019 Document 03 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II 4 6 17.2.b Digital resources The interactive website deliverable 7.2 designed to be seamlessly i an information portal for all interested audiences and ii a workspace through restricted access for consortium members and partners. A quarterly onepage project newsletter disseminated by email and referring readers to recent updates at the web space will strive to maintain the interest of actual and potential endusers. In order to optimize complementarity to other initiatives, these will be proactively documented within the website. The description and updating of these initiatives will form integral part of SeMPERArcticÕs main outreach output, its training curriculum and associated training material. 17.2.c Arctic community level resilience curriculum and associated training material Throughout the project, the SeMPERArctic consortium will work to develop a training curriculum entitled ÔImproving ArcticÕs resilience by using arctic communitiesÕ experiences in overcoming adversityÕ. The curriculum will be designed for use in workshops, classes and webinars to support core skills development for resilience science coconstruction. In the final year of the project the curriculum will be implemented through training material videos, text, maps, exercises, drawing on the lessons learned during the 3 pilot studies. To optimize value and transferability for the user community, the curriculum will be targeted explicitly at three user communities resilience officers working in the arctic, climate studies scientists and arctic studies scientists. For each of these, the curriculum will be organized around a specific learning pathway tailored to meet the needs of the audience. 17.2.d Restituting SeMPERArcticÕs results to the community through creative work During the final months of the project, result sharing workshops will be organized within the three SeMPERArctic pilot communities. The output of these workshop will take the form of locallydriven art form and associated documentaries deliverables d7.5 a, b, c. The purpose of these workshops and art productions is to ensure that the local positive impacts are maximized and that the lessons learned locally are shared with the outside world in a way that is coherent with local values, and social representations. With these art and science experiments the SeMPERArctic consortium will further address the challenge to coconstructing resilience science. Coconstruction process must be culturally mediated, place relevant, and must use various communication channels. The approaches for creating such channels range from not so simple Ôknowledge mediationÕ exercises applied to resilience science, to more complex joint art and science integration experiments. The latter are promising for making resilience science more meaningful in a place, particularly where narratives form the entry point for coconstruction. Local artists are ideally placed to challenge existing narratives and to provoke the exploration of novel narratives. The 177120190620211029.pdfImpact, Engagement, and Dissemination Plan20190620Page 53 Implementation Plan 2019 Document 03 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II 5 6 intermeshing of nature and culture, emotions and reason around resilience experiments implies that approaching local climate through science must be put into perspective by a more intuitive approach that seeks to represent the world as perceived by the senses. Such an approach has been achieved by including the arts in social dynamics together with scientific research and innovation Bilodeau, 2013. Developing a strong connection between art and science enables the rearticulation of the scientific description of the world Latour, 2011. 17.3 Initial foreseen web space structure and foreseen content The web portal will be maintained for at least three years after the end of the project. Th following structure is foreseen. Homepage introduction to the project, recent news The project The study sites The team The funding agencies Documents available to download information leaflets Deliverables Milestones Link to Restricted access area. The concepts and challenges ProjectÕs results Conceptual progress Results of fieldbased enquiries Narratives produced Access to the training curriculums, General introduction User manual ÔImproving ArcticÕs resilience by using arctic communitiesÕ experiences in overcoming adversity.Õ tutorials videos, textbased material, exercises 177120190620211029.pdfImpact, Engagement, and Dissemination Plan20190620Page 54 Implementation Plan 2019 Document 03 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II 6 6 case studies resources The SeMPERArctic resilience enhancement tool; tutorials videos, textbased material, exercises case studies resources Producing resiliencerelevant local art work three examples; tutorials videos, textbased material, exercises case studies resources Section restricted to project members, funding agencies officials and external advisory panel. Milestones and progresses General file sharing areaFTP Agenda, timeline Meeting logistics Organisation Presentations and minutes Discussion forum Database this section containing SeMPERArcticÕs corpora will be made available upon request to external colleagues, with most probably embargo period after the end of the project 177120190620211029.pdfImpact, Engagement, and Dissemination Plan20190620Page 55 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 1 1 18. External funding from other sources including current and pending support Funded by LSCEUVSQ, 15 PM of permanent staff 75 k? 25k? each year, confirmed. Funded by OVSQCEARCUVSQ, 25.4 15 PM of permanent staff 127 k? 42.33k? each year, confirmed. 177120190620211029.pdfExternal Funding20190620Page 56 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 1 8 19. Funding justification UVSQLSCE SALARIES 135 k? 50 k? Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Total 45k? 45 k? 45 k? 135 k? Of which 60k? is requested to the funding agency. External funding of 75 k? comes the salary funding of permanent staff by UVSQ For 27 PM divided as such WP 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 PM 0 0 10 0 0 0 17 TRAVEL 25? Belmont Forum meetingsconferences 2 meetings, 2k?meeting = 4k? Consortium meetings 4x meetings, 1,5 k?meeting = 6k? Fieldwork 3 trips 5k?trip = 15k? CONSUMABLES 3k? Open access fees 2x publications 1.5k? each = 3k? FACILITIES AND EQUIPMENT 4k? Fieldwork appropriate equipment including computer, camera and recorder 4 k? OTHER INCLUDING SUBCONTRACT 4k? Translation service for field work 4k? OVERHEADS 3.7k? 4 % of total = 3.7k? 177120190620211029.pdfFunding Justification20190620Page 57 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 2 8 UVSQCEARC SALARIES YEARLY AND TOTAL Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Total 60k? 60k? 60k? 180k? Of which 53 000 is requested to the funding agency. External funding for 127 k? comes the salary funding of permanent staff by UVSQ 36 PM divided as such WP 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 PM 18 0 0 6 3 0 9 TRAVEL 23.5k? Belmont Forum meetingsconferences 2 meetings, 2k?meeting = 4k? Consortium meetings 3x meetings, 1.5k?meeting = 4.5k? Fieldwork 3 trips 5k?trip = 15k? CONSUMABLES YEARLY AND TOTAL 3k? Open access fees 2x publications 1,5k? each = 3k? FACILITIES AND EQUIPMENT 4.5k? Fieldwork appropriate equipment including computer, camera and recorder 4.5k? OTHER INCLUDING SUBCONTRACT 14.5k? Translation service for field work 4.5k? Artwork in communities funding of local artist 5k? * 2= 10k? OVERHEADS 3.7k? 4 % of total = 3.7k? 177120190620211029.pdfFunding Justification20190620Page 58 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 3 8 Nordregio SALARIES YEARLY AND TOTAL 105k? Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Total 35k? 35k? 35k? 105k? 30 PM divided as such WP 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 PM 0 0 0 13 14 0 3 TRAVEL 25k? Belmont Forum meetingsconferences 2 meetings, 2k?meeting = 4k? Conferences 4 conferences 1.5k?conference = 6k? Fieldwork 3 seasons within communities times 5k? 15k? CONSUMABLES YEARLY AND TOTAL 2k? Open access fees 2x publications 1k? each = 2k? FACILITIES AND EQUIPMENT OTHER INCLUDING SUBCONTRACT 15k? Sub contract to Arctic business circle network key local actor translating community narratives into marketing and strategic outreach for a sustainable tourism development locally. This corresponds to 5k? each year and a total of 15k? OVERHEADS 6.5k? 4 % of total = 6,5 K? 177120190620211029.pdfFunding Justification20190620Page 59 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 4 8 UiBSVT SALARIES YEARLY AND TOTAL 105k? Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Total 39,6k? 20,2k? 20,8k? 81,4k? 30 PM divided as such WP 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 PM 0 3 0 0 3 0 2 TRAVEL14k? Belmont Forum meetings 2 meetings @ ?2000meeting = 4k? Consortium meetings 4x meetings @ ?1000meeting = 4k? Fieldwork 4 trips for interviews ?1000trip = 4k? Conferences 2 trips at ?1000trip = 2k? CONSUMABLES YEARLY AND TOTAL 2k? Open access fees 2x publications @ ?1000 each = ?2000 Transcriptiontranslation 3.4k? FACILITIES AND EQUIPMENT OTHER INCLUDING SUBCONTRACT OVERHEADS 177120190620211029.pdfFunding Justification20190620Page 60 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 5 8 UUCopernicus SALARIES 167.4 k? Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Total 50.7 k? 60.9 k? 55.8 k? 167.4 k? 30 PM divided as such WP 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 PM 0 9 0 0 15.4 0 2 TRAVEL18.2k? Belmont Forum meetingsconferences 2 meetings, 2k?meeting 4k?. Participation in consortium meetings, 4 meetings, with 12 persons 6 K?. Travel for interviews 3.2 K?. Fieldwork in the Arctic 1x 5 K?. CONSUMABLES YEARLY AND TOTAL 9.4k? Open access fees 2x publications 1k? each 2k? Organization of one consortium meeting jointly by DutchNorwegian team 2 K?. Materials for an integration workshop at one of the consortium meetings 0.4 K?. Translation costs for nonEnglish interview data 5 K?. FACILITIES AND EQUIPMENT OTHER INCLUDING SUBCONTRACT 5k? Bench Fee for the postdoc covers conferences, etc. 5 K?. OVERHEADS 177120190620211029.pdfFunding Justification20190620Page 61 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 6 8 NEFU SALARIES 116 k? Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Total 30k? 36k? 50k? 116k? 30 PM divided as such WP 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 PM 12 0 8 11 0 0 3 TRAVEL44.5k? 1 Field work A short field session in Tiksi 14 days per person will be 2,0 K?. The number of field sessions 3. 1. a Travel Costs Transportation costs for 1 person YakutskTiksiBykovskyTiksiYakutsk will be 800 ?. Transportation expenses for the years will be in 2020 2.4 K ? 3 people, in 2021 3.2 K ? 4 people, in 2022 1.6 K ? 2 people. Total transportation costs 7.2 K?. 1.b Overheads Overhead for 1 person YakutskTiksiBykovskyTiksiYakutsk including per diem, hotel and other accommodation for 14 days will be 1200 ?. Overhead costs for the years will be in 2020 3.6 K ? 3 people, in 2021 4.8 K ? 4 people, in 2022 2.4 K ? 2 people. Total overhead 10,8 K?. 2 Consortium meeting The organization of the meeting in Yakutsk scientific workshop will be 2.0 K?. A meeting is scheduled for 2021. 3 Participate to the meetings Participation of 1 person in the meetings will be 1,5 K ?. Transportation costs for 1 person YakutskMoscowcity of the EUMoscowYakutsk will amount to 1.0 K ?. 3.a Transportation costs for the years will be in 2020 2.0 K ? 2 people, in 2021 2.0 K ? 2 people, in 2022 3.0 K ? 3 people. Total transportation costs 7.0 K ?. 177120190620211029.pdfFunding Justification20190620Page 62 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 7 8 3.b Overhead costs for 1 person YakutskMoscowcity of the EUMoscowYakutsk including per diem, hotel and other accommodation for 5 days will be 0.5 K ?. Overhead costs for the years will be in 2020 1.0 K ? 2 people, in 2021 1.0 K ? 2 people, in 2022 1.5 K ? 3 people. Total overhead 3,5 K ?. 4 Belmont Forum meeting Participation of 1 person in the meetings will be 2.0 K ?. Transportation costs for 1 person YakutskMoscowcity of the EUMoscowYakutsk will amount to 1.0 K ?. 4.a Transportation costs for the years will be in 2020 2.0 K ? 2 people, in 2022 2.0 K ? 2 p. Total shipping costs 4.0 K ?. 4.b Overhead costs for 1 person YakutskMoscowEUMoscowYakutsk city including per diem, hotel and other accommodation for 7 days will be 1.0 K ?. Overhead costs for the years will be in 2020 2,0 K ? 2 p, in 2022 2,0 K ? 2 p. Total shipping costs 4.0 K ?. 5 Conferences Participation of 1 person in the conferences will be 1,5 K ?. Transportation costs for 1 person YakutskMoscowcity of the EUMoscowYakutsk will amount to 1.0 K ?. 5.a Transportation costs for the years will be in 2020 2.0 K ? 2 people, in 2021 2.0 K ? 2 people, in 2022 2.0 K ? 2 people. Total transportation costs 6.0 K ?. 5.b Overhead costs for 1 person YakutskMoscowcity of the EUMoscowYakutsk including per diem, hotel and other accommodation for 5 days will be 0.5 K ?. Overhead costs for the years will be in 2020 1.0 K ? 2 people, in 2021 1.0 K ? 2 people, in 2022 1.0 K ? 2 people. Total overhead is 3.0 K ?. CONSUMABLES YEARLY AND TOTAL 5.5k? Open access fees 2x publications 2.5k? each = 5k? Small supplies 0.5k? FACILITIES AND EQUIPMENT 2k? Expenses for the purchase of equipment, incl. laptop, flash cards, tablet, office equipment, spare parts, components for office equipment 2k? OTHER INCLUDING SUBCONTRACT 3k? Translation 3 k? 177120190620211029.pdfFunding Justification20190620Page 63 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 8 8 OVERHEADS 26k 13 % of total expenses 26k? 177120190620211029.pdfFunding Justification20190620Page 64 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 1 5 20. References cited Alexander, D. E. 2013. Resilience and disaster risk reduction an etymological journey. Natural hazards and earth system sciences, 1311, 27072716. Barroca, B., DiNardo, M., & Mboumoua, I. 2013. De la vuln?rabilit? ? la r?silience mutation ou bouleversement. EchoG?o, 24. Baztan J., Cordier M., Huctin J.M., Zhu Z., Vanderlinden J.P. 2017. Life on thin ice Insights from Uummannaq, Greenland for connecting climate science with Arctic communities. Polar Science 13, 100108. Bilodeau, C. 2013. A Climate of Collaboration environmental scientists urge artists to humanize the stories behind the research. American Theatre, 30. Retrieved from httpwww.tcg.orgpublicationsatissuefeaturedstory.cfmstory=9&indexID=29 Blanchard, A., & Vanderlinden, J. P. 2010. Dissipating the fuzziness around interdisciplinarity the case of climate change research. SAPI EN. S. Surveys and Perspectives Integrating Environment and Society, 3.1. Blanchard, A., & Vanderlinden, J. P. 2012. Interdisciplinarit? et outils r?flexifs vers une approche globale des trames vertes urbaines. Conclusion. VertigOla revue ?lectronique en sciences de l'environnement, Horss?rie 12. Blanchard, A., & Vanderlinden, J. P. 2013. Prerequisites to interdisciplinary research for climate change lessons from a participatory action research process in ëledeFrance. International Journal of Sustainable Development, 1612, 122. Box J. E. , Colgan W. T. , Christensen T. R. , Schmidt N. M., Lund M., Parmentier F.J., Brown R., Bhatt U. S., Euskirchen E. S., Romanovsky V. E., Walsh J. E., Overland J. E. , Wang M., Corell R. W., Meier W. N., Wouters B., Mernild S., M?rd J., Pawlak J. and Skovg?rd Olsen M. 2019. Key indicators of Arctic climate change 1971Ð201. Environmental research letter, 14 Box, J. E. 2002. Survey of Greenland instrumental temperature records 18732001. International journal of climatology, 22, 18291847 Brand, F., & Jax, K. 2007. Focusing the meaning s of resilience resilience as a descriptive concept and a boundary object. Ecology and Society, 121, 23. Bravo, M.T.2009. Voices from the sea ice the reception of climate impact narratives. Journal of Historical Geography, 35, 256278 Cappelen, J., Jorgensen, B.V., Lauresne E.V. , Stannius L., and Thomsen R. 2001. The observed climate of Greenland, 195899 with climatology. 177120190620211029.pdfReferences Cited20190620Page 65 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 2 5 Cohendet, P., Creplet, F., & Dupouet, O. 2001. Organisational innovation, communities of practice and epistemic communities the case of Linux. In Economics with heterogeneous interacting agents pp. 303326. Springer Berlin Heidelberg. Cote, M., & Nightingale, A. J. 2012. Resilience thinking meets social theory situating social change in socioecological systems SES research. Progress in Human Geography, 364, 475489. Cruikshank, J. 2000. Social life of stories narrative and knowledge in the Yukon Territory. UBC Press. Da Cunha, C., & Vanderlinden, J. P. 2014. Adaptation aux changements globaux quels apports de la transdisciplinarit?. Revue Franaise de Socio?conomie, 1, 277282. Davidson, J. L., C. Jacobson, A. Lyth, A. DedekorkutHowes, C. L. Baldwin, J. C. Ellison, N. J. Holbrook, M. J. Howes, S. SerraoNeumann, L. SinghPeterson, and T. F. Smith. 2016. Interrogating resilience toward a typology to improve its operationalization. Ecology and Society, 212, 27. De Boer, J., J.A. Wardekker, J.P. van der Sluijs 2010, Framebased guide to situated decisionmaking on climate change. Global Environmental Change, 203, 502510. Dixon, J., & Durrheim, K. 2004. Dislocating identity Desegregation and the transformation of place. Journal of environmental psychology, 244, 455473. Gad, U. P., & Strandsbjerg, J. Eds.. 2018. The Politics of Sustainability in the Arctic Reconfiguring Identity, Space, and Time. AbingdononThames Routledge. Giuliani, M. V. 2003. Theory of attachment and place attachment, in M. Bonnes ed, Psychological Theories for Environmental Issues 137174. AbingdononThames Routledge. Haas, P. 1992. Introduction epistemic communities and international policy coordination. International Organization, 141, 136. Heleniak, T. E. 2009. The role of attachment to place in migration decisions of the population of the Russian North. Polar Geography, 3212, 3160. Ilgen, S., F. Sengers, A. Wardekker 2019. Citytocity learning for urban resilience The case of water squares in Rotterdam and Mexico City. Water, 115, 983. Janif, S., Nunn, P., Geraghty, P., Aalbersberg, W., Thomas, F., & Camailakeba, M. 2016. Value of traditional oral narratives in building climatechange resilience insights from rural communities in Fiji. Ecology and Society, 212. 177120190620211029.pdfReferences Cited20190620Page 66 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 3 5 Kane, I. O., & Vanderlinden, J. P. 2015. LÕutilisation du concept polys?mique de r?silience une analyse empirique en zone c?tire. VertigOla revue ?lectronique en sciences de l'environnement, Horss?rie 23. Kaplan, H. B. 2005. Understanding the concept of resilience. In Handbook of resilience in children pp. 3947. Springer, Boston, MA. Latour, B., 2011. Waiting for Gaia. Composing the common world through art and politics. Paper presented at the Lecture given for the launching of SPEAP, French Institute, London. Malinauskaite, L., Cook, D., Dav?ðsd?ttir, B., ?gmundard?ttir, H., & Roman, J. 2019. Ecosystem services in the Arctic a thematic review. Ecosystem Services, 36, 100898. Meerow, S., Newell, J. P., & Stults, M. 2016. Defining urban resilience A review. Landscape and urban planning, 147, 3849. Moser, S., Meerow, S., Arnott, J., & JackScott, E. 2019. The turbulent world of resilience interpretations and themes for transdisciplinary dialogue. Climatic Change, 15312, 2140. Paavola, S., Lipponen, L., & Hakkarainen, K. 2004. Models of Innovative Knowledge Communities and Three Metaphors of Learning. Review of Educational Research, 74, 557576. Prokkola, E. K. 2007. Crossborder regionalization and tourism development at the SwedishFinnish BorderÒDestination Arctic CircleÓ. Scandinavian Journal of Hospitality and Tourism, 72, 120138. Raymond, C. M., Brown, G., & Weber, D. 2010. The measurement of place attachment Personal, community, and environmental connections. Journal of environmental psychology, 304, 422434. Rommetveit, K., Gunnarsd?ttir, K., Jepsen, K. S., Bertelsson, M., Verax, F., & Strand, R. 2013. The TECHNOLIFE project an experimental approach to new ethical frameworks for emerging science and technology. International Journal of Sustainable Development, 1612, 2345. Sancho Reinoso, A., & Helgenberger, S. 2015 Guidelines on Open KnowledgeImproving the societal benefit of climate research activities, JPI Climate May, accessed online on June 19 2019, httpwww.jpiclimate.eumediadefault.aspxemmaorg10862502JPI+Climate+Guidelines+on+Open+Knowledge.pdf 177120190620211029.pdfReferences Cited20190620Page 67 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 4 5 Stammler, F. 2013. Narratives of adaptation and innovation ways of being mobile and mobile technologies among reindeer nomads in the Russian Arctic. Nomadic and indigenous spaces Productions and cognitions, 221245. Statistique Canada 2014. Survey of Emergency Preparedness and Resilience available httpswww.statcan.gc.caengsurveyhousehold5208 visited June 19 2019 Tesar, C., Dubois, M. A., & Shestakov, A. 2016. Toward strategic, coherent, policyrelevant arctic science. Science, 3536306, 13681370. UN 2015. Transforming our World The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. United Nations, New York. UN 2016. Habitat III The New Urban Agenda. United Nations, New York. Vanderlinden, J.P., Pacteau, C., Joussaume, S., & Blanc, N. 2012. Structuration novatrice de la recherche interdisciplinaire sur les changements climatiques, une exp?rience francilienne. VertigO, Special issue 12. Retrieved from httpvertigo.revues.org11882. Vanderlinden, J.P., Quenet, G., Da Cunha, C., & Baztan, J. 2015. Paradigm shifts, coastal zones and adaptation to fast paced change Moving toward transdisciplinary community centred approaches. In J. Baztan, O. Chouinard, B. Jorgensen, P. Tett, J.P. Vanderlinden, & L. Vasseur Eds., Coastal Zones Solutions for the 21st Century pp. 39. NewYork Elsevier. Veland, S., & Lynch, A. H. 2017. Arctic ice edge narratives scale, discourse and ontological security. Area, 491, 917. Walker, B., Holling, C.S., Carpenter, S.R., Kinzig, A. 2004. Resilience, adaptability and transformability in socialecological systems. Ecology & Society, 9, 5. Wardekker, A. 2018. Resilience principles as a tool for exploring options for urban resilience. Solutions, 91. Wardekker, A. in press. Framing 'resilient cities' System versus community focused interpretations of urban climate resilience. In Urban resilience Methodologies, tools and evaluation. Springer, Cham. Wardekker, J.A. 2016. Framing resilience social uncertainty in designing urban climate resilience. Paper presented at the Nordic Adaptation Conference 2016, Bergen, Norway, 2931 August 2016. httpsdspace.library.uu.nlhandle1874341569 Wardekker, J.A., A. de Jong, J.M. Knoop, J.P. van der Sluijs 2010. Operationalising a resilience approach to adapting an urban delta to uncertain climate changes. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 776, 987998. 177120190620211029.pdfReferences Cited20190620Page 68 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project ÒSense Making, Place attachment, and Extended networks, as sources of Resilience in the ArcticÓ 5 5 Wenger, E. 1998. Communities of practice learning, meaning, and identity. Cambridge Cambridge University Press. Wexler, L. 2009. Identifying colonial discourses in Inupiat young people's narratives as a way to understand the no future of Inupiat youth suicide. American Indian and Alaska Native Mental Health Research The Journal of the National Center, 161, 124. 177120190620211029.pdfReferences Cited20190620Page 69 Belmont Forum Ð CRA Arctic II SeMPERArctic project Sense Making, Place attachment and Extended networks as sources of Resilience in the Arctic. SeMPERArctic LETTER OF SUPPORT Content Page Site Letter of support of 2 Tiksi ASSOCIATION OF THE INDIGENOUS MINORITIES OF THE NORTH OF THE REPUBLIC OF SAKHA YAKUTIA 3 Tiksi Ad hoc translation of the preceding page 4 Tiksi MINISTRY FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ARCTIC AND THE PEOPLES OF THE NORTH OF THE REPUBLIC OF SAKHA YAKUTIA 5 Tiksi Ad hoc translation of the preceding page 6 Tiksi THE REPUBLIC OF SAKHA YAKUTIA MUNICIPAL FORMATION "BULUNSKY ULUS DISTRICT" 7 Tiksi Ad hoc translation of the preceding page 8 Tiksi and broader regional HEAD OF THE REPUBLIC OF SAKHA 9 Tiksi and broader Russian Federation Association National Arctic Research and Education Consortium 10 Uummannaq Uummannaq Polar Institute Uummannaq Children Home 11 Uummannaq Uummannaq Seasafaris, tourism operator. 12 Uummannaq Uummannaq school principal 13 Ittoqqortoormit Ejnar Mikkelsenila Aluarpia, the school of Ittoqqortoormiit 14 Ittoqqortoormit Nanu Travel 15 Ittoqqortoormit Greenlandia expedition 16 Greenlandic sites Arctic circle buisness 177120190620211029.pdfSupporting Letters20190620Page 70 177120190620211029.pdfSupporting Letters20190620Page 71 AD HOC TRANSLATION OF THE PRECEDING PAGE ASSOCIATION OF THE INDIGENOUS MINORITIES OF THE NORTH OF THE REPUBLIC OF SAKHA YAKUTIA 677022 Yakutsk, ul. Chernyshevskogo 14, room. 207 tel. +79142294831, +79248673245 www.yakutiakmns.org yakutiakmns@mail.ru June 17, 2019 No. 250619 The Association of Indigenous Minorities of the North of the Republic of Sakha Yakutia is ready to support the SeMPERArctic research project Sense Making, Place attachment and Extended networks as sources of Resilience in the Arctic, the coordinator of the Russian team ? Inga Nikulkina, which is part of the Belmont Forum Collaborative Research Action on Resilience in Rapidly Changing Arctic Systems CRA Arctic II, addressing key areas of Arctic resilience understanding and action. One of the key areas for the implementation of this project will be the Bulunsky district, which is the residence of the indigenous minorities of the North. We propose to include Vyacheslav Shadrin in the project team, VicePresident of the Association of Indigenous Minorities of the North of the Sakha Republic Yakutia, who will represent the Association in the project and coordinate communication with the Association of Indigenous Minorities of the North of Bulunsky District, which will assist in the conduct of expeditionary research and project implementation. Respectfully, President of the Association, People's Writer of Yakutia A.V. Krivoshapkin 177120190620211029.pdfSupporting Letters20190620Page 72 MuHucrepcrBotro pa3BHTr,rro AprrunHIr AeJraM rrapoAoB CeeepaPecny6nr.uclr Caxa flrcyrun Caxa Opocuyy6yJryKOTr{rrApnrurcaur,r cafi r,rnHapr,rbrra yoHrraxoTyfy rropyoTTap Ar,braJraJrapr,r [apMr{HrrcrHOpHcrH6e're{nn npe4r,flBJrerrnfl rro Mecry rpe6orarrunyr. r{epurrnreBcxoro, [,. 74, r. 5lxyrcx, 671018, ret. 506263, Qaxc 450683Ernail arktika@sakha. gov.ru http www. sakha. gov.rularktikarr, f,r.rna l\b or l9 r.llncr,uo rroAAeplrffir4MznzcrepcrBo rro pa3BzTr{ro Apr<rIaru v AenaM FrapoAoB CeeepaPecny6nrarz Caxa flryrzx roroBo noAAepKarb HayqHbrfr rrpoeKr SeMPERArctic Sense Making, Place attachment and Extended networks as sources ofResilience in the Arctic, KoopAl4Harop poccuircxoir KoMaHAbr HrzrynrzHa WHraBra4zrrrapoBHa, CBoy r4M. M.K. Auuocona, .rrBrqrouerocs qacllroMeKAyHapoAHoro IrpoeKTa EemvoHTcKoro Sopylra uo accJreAoBarelr,cxofrAesrenbHo crLI <<Xtzgnecn o co Snocrb Sblcrp oMeHrrrotq vrxa fl Apr<rz.re cKr4x cr4 creMCllAprrnxa II> Belmont Forum Collaborative Research Action on Resiliencein Rapidly Changing Arctic Systems CRA Arctic II, HarrpaBJreHHr,rfi Hanol{I4MaHrre u 4eitcrlsufl B KJrrorIeBLIx o6racrqx Ku3Hecnoco6nocrr{ Apxrraxu.OAnzv r43 Tpex KJIIoT{eBbrx pafroFroB peantrcagv naFruoro npoeKTa 6y4erEynyncrzfr pafion Pecuy6nzr<u Caxa SIxyrux, flBrrflrorrJnfrcfl. MecroMnpoxl4BaHr{;l Kop eHHbIX MaJrorrr4cJreHHbrx HapoIoB Cen ep a.3 alre crareJlb Mr4Hr4 crp aM.A. llorotaes177120190620211029.pdfSupporting Letters20190620Page 73 AD HOC TRANSLATION OF THE PRECEDING PAGE MINISTRY FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ARCTIC AND THE PEOPLES OF THE NORTH OF THE REPUBLIC OF SAKHA YAKUTIA ul. Chernyshevskogo 14, Yakutsk, 677018, tel. 506263, fax 450683 Email arktika@sakha.gov.ru httpsarktika.sakha.gov.ru 18.06.2019 No. To whom It May Concern Letter of support The Ministry for the Development of the Arctic and the Peoples of the North of the Republic of Sakha Yakutia is ready to support the SeMPERArctic research project Sense Making, Place attachment and Extended networks as sources of Resilience in the Arctic, the coordinator of the Russian team ? Inga Nikulkina, M. K. Ammosov NorthEastern Federal University, which is part of the Belmont Forum Collaborative Research Action on Resilience in Rapidly Changing Arctic Systems CRA Arctic II, addressing key areas of Arctic resilience understanding and action. One of the key areas for the implementation of this project will be the Bulunsky district of the Republic of Sakha Yakutia, which is the residence of the indigenous minorities of the North. Deputy Minister M. A. Pogodaev 177120190620211029.pdfSupporting Letters20190620Page 74 177120190620211029.pdfSupporting Letters20190620Page 75 AD HOC TRANSLATION OF THE PRECEDING PAGETHE REPUBLIC OF SAKHA YAKUTIA MUNICIPAL FORMATION "BULUNSKY ULUS DISTRICT" Ul. Trusov a, 6, p. Tiksi. 678400, tel. 841167 52 2 93, fax 53 1 79 dated 14.06.2019 ?229 No. The Administration of the Municipal Formation ?Bulunsky Ulus District of the Sakha Republic Yakutia is ready to support the Se MPERArctic research project Sense Making, Place attachment and Extended networks as sources of Resilience in the Arctic, the coordinator of the Russian team ? Inga Nikulkina , wh ich is part of the Belmont Forum Collaborative Research Action on Resilience in Rapidly Changing Arctic Systems CRA Arctic II , address ing key areas of A rctic resilience understanding and action . We propose the inclusion of Vyacheslav Shadrin, Vice Presid ent of the Association of Indigenous Minorities of the North of the Sakha Republic Yakutia, who will represent the Association in the project and coordinate communication with the Association of Indigenous Minorities of the North of Bulunsky District. Bu lunsky district is one of the three key areas of this project, being the residence of the indigenous peoples of the North ? the Evenks and the Evens. For its part, the Administration of the "Bulunsky Ulus District" municipality undertakes to assist in th e conduct of expeditionary research and project implementation. Acting Head V.M. Spiridonova177120190620211029.pdfSupporting Letters20190620Page 76   ???????? ?????????? ??????? ?? ??? ?? ????? ?2?0?????? .??? _?????? ?????????????? ??????????????«?Se? ?MMP?EERRR?????????«?Se? ? ? ?20 ?. ?A? r cccccccccc? _____________ ?.?.??????? ?????.?. ?????????? ???????? ?????????????? ??????? «SeMPERArctic»????????? ??????? ???????!t?i?»??????? ????! ?2?0?????? .??? _????? 0???2?????2 i2???»????»!B »??C»!B 0??2? DEFG?H?ISJM?J _DEK?E F???K?? G??JE ?MM?J??EKM ?K ?LMEKE KEMR?S?? ?? ??eSJE? ? M HE????EKJE ?K M?E ISJM?J?? »?0????2»»!B »? ??2?02C2»?2 ???BC????? ??N???? ????C2???? ?2???»?? ? ???N? ? ?????O»??OP N???C ????2????»?? 0? ???BC????? _??N»2?0????»???? ?!???i2»?PQ???? t???C2???? ???2i ? 2?? ?!????B N»?C?i??OP ??? ?2?0?????? .??? _????????????????????? ???? ??????177120190620211029.pdfSupporting Letters20190620Page 77 177120190620211029.pdfSupporting Letters20190620Page 78 Meeqqat Angerlarsimaffiat Ð B¿rnehjemmet Uummannaq PO Box 99, 3961 Uummannaq, Greenland Tel +299 951539 Ð Fax +299 951639 Ð Email bhjumq@nanoq.gl Uummannaq, 10062019 TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN We confirm our interest in the international research project SeMPERArctic, coordinated by Jeanne Gherardi, climate scientist at the LSCE research center, in close cooperation with the CEARC research center. Our interest has been attracted by the focus that the SeMPERArctic team puts on how knowledge of local experiences can foster individual and collective resilience processes which, we strongly believe, eventually affect the communityÕs future. Our Uummannaq community would be one of the studied sites of the project and we trust that this project will allow knowledge coproduction between researchers and local community members in a mutual benefit. This ethical and efficient approach is secured by the facts that we UPI have been partners of the CEARC research center since its creation and that one CEARC member of the SeMPERArctic project team is known by many Uummannaq inhabitants for at least two decades JeanMichel Huctin worked with our institution in many projects over the years, conducted his own anthropological studies in our community and has recently been discussing the SeMPERArctic project with us. In addition to secure logistic needs for the research team when working in our community of Uummannaq, the UPI will be involved in the research process itself. We are especially interested to collect as many stories as possible of young people, former residents of our residentialcare institution, who overcame childhood adverse experiences and succeeded to be parents themselves without reproducing these adverse experiences on their own children. Better understanding the resilience process that helps young people overcome the worst traumas would be of vital importance for our work with youth in our Childrens home, for our local community as well as for Greenland. Therefore we welcome the SeMPERArctic team in Uummannaq and we are confident to become a trustful and efficient partner of the research project. Best regards, Ann Andreasen Director Childrens home Uummannaq Uummannaq Polar Institute 177120190620211029.pdfSupporting Letters20190620Page 79 §r*;Uummannaq, June 19, 2019Support letter to the the SeMPERArctic projectAs a director of Uummannaq Seasafaris ApS, atourism company operating in Uummannaq,Greenland, I wish to bring my support to the SeMPERArctic research project.We already participated in a previous research project conducted in Uummannaq by JeanMichel Huctin and other researchers from the University of Versailles SaintQuentinenYvelines, France. With this new project, the goal is to go further with a deeper collaborationthat will better address the local needs of our community, with a special focus on tourismbusiness development that could be relevant for our company. By collecting local storiesrevealing the strength of our past and presentday efforts to cope with climate andenvironmental changes as well as economic, social and political challenges, researchers hopeto identiff new ways of preserving our cultural heritage and empowering the community.I already been speaking with JeanMichel Huctin about possible collaboration for researchpurposes in Uummannaq in April 2019.I'm happy to see a new concrete opportunity with thisSeMPERArctic project I look forward to welcoming the project researchers in Uummannaqand start our collaboration.Best Regards,4A,M\Seasafaris ApSEmail info@uummannaqseasafaris. glTel +299560703faxwww. uu mmannaq seasafari s. glhttps lwww.facebook. comu u m m a n naqseasafaris177120190620211029.pdfSupporting Letters20190620Page 80 177120190620211029.pdfSupporting Letters20190620Page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pdfSupporting Letters20190620Page 82 Ittoqqortoormiit June 18, 2019 TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN RE Support letter to the the SeMPERArctic project My name is Mette Pike Barselajsen, Im director here in Nanu Travel Aps here in Ittoqqortoormiit North East Greenland. Nanu Travel is professional in dealings with foreign outfitters and companies that wish to spend short or longer time in the village or the biggest fjord in the world Scoresby Sund. Many companies have since discovered the remote village of Ittoqqortoormiit with its 350 inhabitants. Most of them use Nanu Travel services and expert knowledge of the area. I wish to express the support of Nanu Travel to the SeMPER Arctic project We support the SeMPERArctic project for two important reasons 1 We believe that the collection and sharing of local stories will help strengthen our community through increased visibility, which is especially important for our tourism. 2 We strongly hope that SeMPERArctic scientists will be able to better understand our research needs and carry out work that is really useful to us. We contributed to the design of the SeMPERArctic project by meeting and sharing the possible topics first with Vincent Hilaire, head of Greenlandia in August 2015, and secondly, accompanying JeanPaul Vanderlinden and Vincent Hilaire in the scoping work carried out in our city of Ittoqqortoormiit in May 2019. Best Regards Venlig hilsen Inussiarnersumik inuulluaqqusillunga Mette Pike Barselajsen Nanu Travel ApS email nanu@nanutravel.com kontor +299991280 mandag ?torsdag 12.0014.00 lokal tid, fredag 09001400 lokal tid fax +299991070 www.nanutravel.dk www.facebook.comnanutravel 177120190620211029.pdfSupporting Letters20190620Page 83 177120190620211029.pdfSupporting Letters20190620Page 84 177120190620211029.pdfSupporting Letters20190620Page 85